On December 30, 2020, Argentina joined the short list of countries where abortion is a right without restrictions on motive, that is, without the pregnant person having to specify a reason for requesting termination, within the first 14 weeks of pregnancy. The bill, approved in December after receiving 38 votes in favour, 29 against, and one abstention, was formalized on January 14, 2021. Although in some regions of Argentina abortions have already been carried out, the passing of the law on Access to Voluntary Termination of Pregnancy (IVE) has sparked what seems to be the next historic struggle—to ensure its implementation. Less than a month before the new law came into effect across the country, Judge Marta Beatriz Aucar de Trotti, the head of the Civil and Commercial Court No. 19 of the city of Resistencia, in Chaco province, accepted an appeal filed by a group of citizens arguing that life begins at conception and that the law is contrary to this. As a result, at the end of January 2021, Aucar de Trotti implemented a precautionary measure that suspended the implementation, in Chaco province, of the IVE law. The ruling was immediately appealed by the civil society organisation Unidos por la Diversidad on the grounds that it was a federal and not a provincial law, then by the ministry of health calling for the case to be heard by a judge with national jurisdiction, and finally by a Chaco State prosecutor, Cecilia Fernández Almendra. However, the precautionary measure remains in force; so although the right to legal abortion is valid throughout the country, its application is currently suspended in Chaco. As well as the ruling in Chaco, an appeal and a legal action have been filed in Córdoba province against the Argentinian president, Alberto Fernández, and the parliamentarians who voted in favour of the law. The action filed by the civil society organization Derechos Humanos y Violencia de Género (Human Rights and Gender Violence) includes a request for an impeachment trial against the president and argues that the law is unconstitutional. The use of various tactics to get the IVE Law declared unconstitutional and the request for precautionary measures do not come as a surprise, as groups opposing the law said on social networks that “No unconstitutional law is going to discourage us.” Seguimos luchando en contra del aborto, seguimos defendiendo al inocente, seguimos empoderando a la mujer con educación, con herramientas, con amor, en una sociedad rota. Ninguna ley inconstitucional nos va a desarmar. Ninguna ley inconstitucional va a cambiar nuestra postura. pic.twitter.com/W3D5rFrS7F — Unidad Provida ? (@unidadprovidaok) December 30, 2020 We continue to fight against abortion, we continue to defend the innocent, we continue to empower women with education, with tools, with love, in a broken society. No unconstitutional law is going to discourage us. No unconstitutional law is going to change our stance. In December 2019, a year before the law on abortion was passed, the Medical College of Misiones Province announced the creation of a Register of Conscientious Objectors, “in order to protect the right of those who, for moral, ethical, philosophical, cultural, religious or ideological reasons, consider themselves exempt from performing medical acts that are in contradiction with their convictions.” The request to be included in the register is voluntary, personal and confidential. “The provincial decree in force establishes that the medical institution cannot object, and the doctor, in any such case should immediately refer [the patient to another doctor],” explained Luis Flores, president of the College of Doctors of Misiones, and he recognized that “the law is clear about the doctor's obligation to refer [a patient], and there is no discussion about that”. In contrast to the provinces of Chaco, Cordoba, and Misiones, the law is being implemented smoothly in other regions. According to statements by the Minister for Women, Gender and Diversity, Elisabeth Gómez Alcorta, the city and province of Buenos Aires, and La Pampa, are among the districts that are best implementing the law. After the law on abortion came into force, Estefania Cioffi, a doctor, feminist activist, and member of the Network of Health Professionals for the Right to Decide, shared an image on Instagram of the first prescription of misoprostol (one of the most commonly used drugs for abortion) in Argentina, with her stamp and signature. “Social justice is being able to decide,” Cioffi wrote next to the image she uploaded from the poor 1-11-14 neighbourhood in the middle of Buenos Aires city, where she works as a general practitioner.
Indigenous Review
Abortion in Argentina: The struggle continues
Tags