HEN women tell us men that we'll never be able to understand them, as they pretty often do, I think they usually mean that it's because we idealize them; though they aren't likely to admit this to be their meaning precisely. Anyhow, they get quite a little pleasure out of our not understanding them, and on that account it seems queer how seldom they mystify us on purpose.
The most mystifying woman I ever knew was one who hadn't the slightest idea she was puzzling anybody, and she showed genuine amazement when she found out that her conduct was generally thought impossible to understand.
What's more, the other women were as befogged about her as the men were; or at least they said so. They talked about her by the hour—there were times when they didn't seem able to talk about anything else—and I don't suppose that in the whole history of the world one particular question has been asked oftener than the question the women in our town were always asking one another: “Well, what do you think of Geraldine now?”
For my part, I never pretended to understand Geraldine Wygate at all. That is to say, I sometimes understood what her motives were, I suppose; but I didn't understand why she had them. I knew her well, too; I knew her even before she was old enough to have any motives. Our house was only two doors and a vacant lot north of the big stone-trimmed brick “Wygate Mansion.”
HE was an only child, but not a spoiled one; though she was born when her parents were both well along in middle-age, and they were certainly as indulgent with her as she wished them to be. Her father was what a moderate-sized town used to call “a fairly rich man;” and he was able and willing to give Geraldine just about anything a young girl could ask for; but she didn't ask him for a great deal. I remember when he gave her a pony and a basket-cart on her fourteenth birthday, she took so little interest in them that after a month or so he sold them. About all that Geraldine seemed to want was a fox terrier. She always had one kind or another of a little dog with her, wherever she went.
She kept to herself a good deal, though she was sprightly enough when she happened to be with other young people; and at the age when the rest of us were beginning to be susceptible, and the girls talked boy and the boys talked girl—I mean from about fifteen on to the time of getting seriously engaged and married, in the twenties—Geraldine really didn't appear to understand what it was all about.
She didn't once show the slightest personal interest in any of the boys or young men, and none of us exhibited any symptoms of that kind of interest in her. Moreover, this was at the time when all of the young people she'd been growing up with were “pairing off,” so to speak, and weren't much interested in anything else or talking about anything else. She was amiable; but the talk seemed to bore her, as if it were about some technical subject she'd never studied and couldn't feel any interest in at all. When it came to that, Geraldine lived inclosed on the other side of a blank wall, and at twenty-four she was still living in the same inclosure.
She wasn't a beautiful girl by any means, but she wasn't homely, either. She was small, and light-stepping and quick, with bright dark eyes that never seemed to look at anything more than a second or two. She had pretty hands and wavy hair-colored hair; and her features were pleasant—the type we used to call “piquant.” So it wasn't her looks that kept the young men from falling in love with her. It was that queer invisible wall surrounding her; though she hadn't put it there herself on purpose, by any means.
The mothers of the young men liked Geraldine Wygate. They were always telling us what a “self-respecting” girl she was—so much more admirable than the “pushing” sort we seemed to favor—and they wondered why we didn't show her more attention. When they asked us about that, we weren't able to give very satisfactory answers, though my cousin Joe Buell once came pretty near the truth of the matter.
T was a Sunday afternoon, not long after lunch; and Joe and I were lounging in their library, killing time until it got late enough for us to start on a round of “Sunday calls'—a customary procedure with us. Aunt Sallie asked us if we were going to the Wygates', and when we said, “No,” she asked Joe, “Why not?” a little sharply.
“I don't see any reason you can't show Geraldine more attention than you do,” she said. “Geraldine is a fine, self-respecting girl.”
“You might as well ask me to show more attention to sister Bella,” Joe told his mother. “Bella would be just as pleased, and so would I.”