The petitioners were found guilty of violating the President's order of August 23, 1917, by receiving margins above those prescribed for coal jobbers. Both causes present the same fundamental questions and one opinion will suffice.
The Lever Act, 'An act to provide further for the national security and defense by encouraging the production, conserving the supply, and controlling the distribution of food products and fuel,' approved August 10, 1917, c. 53, 40 Stat. 276, 284, 286 (Comp. St. 1918, Comp. St. Ann. Supp. 1919, §§ 3115 1/8 q, 3115 1/8 qq), provides:
'Sec. 25. That the President of the United States shall be, and he is hereby, authorized and empowered, whenever and wherever in his judgment necessary for the efficient prosecution of the war, to fix the price of coal and coke, wherever and whenever sold, either by producer or dealer, to establish rules for the rugulation of and to regulate the method of production, sale, shipment, distribution, apportionment, or storage thereof among dealers and consumers, domestic or foreign; said authority and power may be exercised by him in each case through the agency of the Federal Trade Commission during the war or for such part of said time as in his judgment may be necessary. * *
'Whoever shall, with knowledge that the prices of any such commodity have been fixed as herein provided, ask, demand, or receive a higher price, or whoever shall, with knowledge that the regulations have been prescribed as herein provided, violate or refuse to conform to any of the same, shall, upon conviction, be punished by fine of not more than $5,000, or by imprisonment for not more than two years, or both. Each independent transaction shall constitute a separate offense.'
'Sec. 26. That any person carrying on or employed in commerce among the several states, or with foreign nations, or with or in the territories or other possessions of the United States in any article suitable for human food, fuel, or other necessaries of life, who, either in his individual capacity or as an officer, agent, or employee of a corporation or member of a partnership carring on or employed in such trade, shall store, acquire, or hold, or who shall destroy or make away with any such article for the purpose of limiting the supply thereof to the public or affecting the market price thereof in such commerce, whether temporarily or otherwise, shall be deemed guilty of a felony and, upon conviction thereof, shall be punished by a fine of not more than $5,000 or by imprisonment for not more than two years, or both. * * *'
On August 21, 1917, after prescribing a schedule of prices for bituminous coal at the mine, the President said:
'It is provisional only. It is subject to reconsideration when the whole metnod of administering the fuel supplies of the country shall have been satisfactorily organized and put into operation. Subsequent measures will have as their object a fair and equitable control of the distribution of the supply and of the prices not only at the mines but also in the hands of the middlemen and the retailers.'
August 23, 1917, pending further investigation and determination, it was ordered by the President:
'A coal jobber is defined as a person (or other agency) who purchases and resells coal to coal dealers or to consumers without physically handling it on, over, or throught his own vehicle, dock, trestle, or yard. For the buying and selling of bituminous coal a jobber shall not add to his purchases price a gross margin in excess of 15 cents per ton of 2,000 pounds, nor shall the combined gross margins of any number of jobbers who buy and sell a given shipment or shipments of bituminous coal exceed 15 cents per ton of 2,000 pounds.'
September 6, 1917, the Fuel Administrator directed that--
'Contracts relating to bituminous coal made before the proclamation of the President on August 21, and contracts relating to anthractite coal made before the President's proclamation of August 23, are not affected by these proclamations, provided the contracts are bona fide in character and are enforceable at law.'
[On August 23 the President issued an order fixing prices for anthracite coal at the mines, effective September 1st.]
A statement and order by the Fuel Administrator, dated September 7, 1917, contained the following paragraphs: 'A very large proportion of the coal supply available for the coming winter is under contract. These contracts, which are allowed to stand for, the present, were made prior to the President's proclamation and very largely limit the amount which may be placed on sale at retail prices based on the President's order.