De Lee, of Chicago, “During the puerperium and lactation, insanity is a not infrequent disease,” and from his discussion of it he very apparently holds it as an entity. (P. 373.)

Tweedy & Wrench discuss insanity at more length than any of the other authors and must be convinced that it is a definite disease. (P. 401.)

Nashville Journal of Medicine and Surgery — Part 10

Edgar refers to the “essential puerperal psychoses” and discussed their etiology and time of occurrence very definitely. (P. 800.)

Nashville Journal of Medicine and Surgery — Part 10

The most comprehensive work on this subject, however, is that in the _Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology_ of the British Empire, of Robert Jones, Superintendent of London County Asylum, Claybury, England, and to quote him is most convincing. “Of the specially puerperal cases—and it is in this period that I recognize a special form of insanity—more suffered from mania than melancholia.”

Nashville Journal of Medicine and Surgery — Part 10

Having covered a fair field of literature in this subject of definition we must now seriously consider the question—Have we or have we not a definite disease? Shall we go on to discuss this subject at greater length or shall we put it in the category of a broken wrist or an attack of diphtheria, either of which might occur after the time that any woman had had a baby? If I should say the latter, I should have to conclude this paper and take my seat. So let us go a little farther along and discuss its frequency before the question is answered.

In reference to its frequency, we find among the authorities a great deal of variation and it again shakes our faith in the value of statistics.

In an edition of forty-one years ago of Fordyce Barker’s “Puerperal Diseases,” he gives the ratio of cases of puerperal mania to total labors in Bellevue as 1–80. I have purposely referred to the age of this book because I shall refer to it again in discussing an attributed etiological factor. Not long ago after this work appeared, McLeod took the statistics of births in England and Wales for four years (1878–82) and found the proportion of women committed for puerperal insanity was 1,794–3,500,000 labors, or 1–2000. Baker himself was interested in the variation of statistics and explains part of the difference from the fact that there were many unmarried women at Bellevue; and while there were also among the foreign records, in the old countries, the fact of being a mother and not a wife was felt far less keenly, if at all than in America! (Pp. 160–191.)