Regarding row “II” we may conclude that if E is true, then O is likewise true, but both A and I are false.
As to rows “III” and “IV,” granting the truth of the I propositions, “Some men are wise” and “Some men are mortal,” we are able to assert that of the two A propositions, “All men are wise,” and “All men are mortal,” the first is false while the second is true. A is, therefore, indeterminate, or doubtful. Of the O propositions, “Some men are not wise,” is true while, “Some men are not mortal,” is false. Therefore, O is doubtful. Both of the E propositions are false. Hence, the conclusion relative to rows “III” and “IV” is: If I is true, A and O are doubtful, while E is false.
Concerning rows “V” and “VI” it will be seen without further explanation that if O is true, then E and I are doubtful and A is false.
The conditions of opposition are easily comprehended and remembered when recourse is made to the following scheme:
A E I O If A be true true false true false If E be true false true false true If I be true doubt false true doubt If O be true false doubt doubt true
To use the above scheme, read horizontally from left to right. For example: If A be true, then all in the row opposite obtains; that is, A is true, E is false, I is true, and O is false. (We take it for granted that the student will see that the first column belongs to A, the second to E, the third to I, and the fourth to O.) If E be true, then A is false, E is true, I is false, O is true, etc.
The whole of opposition is comprehended in _two facts_ which are based upon _one principle_. This is the principle: _Whatever may be said of the entire class may be said of a part of that class._ To put it in another way: Whatever is affirmed of all may be affirmed of some, or, Whatever is denied of all may be denied of some. To illustrate:
Accepted truth: All planets rotate. (A) Accepted inference: Some planets rotate. (I) or Accepted truth: No planet is a sun. (E) Accepted inference: Some planets are not suns. (O)
These are the two facts: First, _a particular affirmative may be derived from a universal affirmative_. Second, _a particular negative may be derived from a universal negative_. Or, more briefly: _An I may be derived from an A, and an O from an E_.