Mr. O'CONNELL. I simply wanted to make it clear to the whole committee, as I explained it to the chairman yesterday, that it was only last Saturday that we knew what the situation was and knew what the provisions of this bill were.
I might say at the outset that the companies which I represent are not members of that class which Mr. Putnam so delicately denominated as pirates. We are here to protect industries in which there are invested millions of dollars. It has also been said by some of these special interests which are appearing in favor of the bill, in elegant language, that we were "butters-in" at the eleventh hour, and that we are here for the purpose of a hold-up. If protecting our business makes us butters-in and hold-up artists, then we come under that definition.
I want to say furthermore, at the outset, that we have no particular controversy or quarrel with those very eminent gentlemen, Mr. Herbert and Mr. Sousa. It is perfectly proper for them to seek to get all they possibly can from the products of their genius, but we are all a great deal too sentimentally inclined toward them and their possessions because of the many hours of delight they have given to every one of us.
Here is our position, and I will try to outline it as briefly as I possibly can: A number of years ago in the city of New York, within the last decade, a number of gentlemen interested in a manufacturing concern, one of the pioneers in the piano-playing industry, had the foresight to realize that the industry was destined to become one in which there were millions of dollars of profit, followed the conclusion that they would like to get for themselves all of the millions in that particular industry. The question was how to achieve and attain that result. Naturally they turned to the patent laws, to get monopolies under patents covering not only the machines themselves, but also the music rolls, without which the machines could not be operated, and machinery for cutting such music rolls.
Applications were made on their behalf for hundreds of patents, both on the machine and on the music rolls, and on machines for cutting the music rolls. Before they had gone very far, however, it developed that the patent laws would not afford them a monopoly of the machines or the music rolls, because of the fact that they could not get and control a basic patent, for the reasons that in the first place the operation by means of wind instruments, vacuums, etc., of an automatic playing device was as old as pipe organs, and furthermore that the perforated music roll or perforated music sheet was also as old as the very ancient hand organ. Therefore they saw that it was utterly impossible for them to obtain the monopoly which they wanted under the patent laws, and naturally the next thing for them to consider was: Can we not attain the required result through the copyright laws?