[Footnote 235: "Parva contentiones, nisi perpetuae sint, divortium non inducunt."--_Ref. leg. ecc.: ap._ JEAFFRESON, _op. cit._, II, 321.]

[Footnote 236: JEAFFRESON, _op. cit._, II, 321.]

A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Volume 2 (of 3) — Part 77

The report prepared by the commission never received the sanction of the king; nor does it appear that any authoritative change in the canon law relating to divorce was ever made until the present century. Nevertheless the _Reformatio Legum_ "is a work of great authority, showing the recognized opinion and sentiment of the church of England at that time and containing the views of the first reformers."[238] The principle represented by it was carried out in practice, though it may well be doubted whether, as is sometimes urged,[239] the decrees of the ecclesiastical court ever went so far as expressly to grant dissolution of wedlock. According to the ancient form of judgment, divorce was probably still pronounced only _a mensa et thoro_; but, whatever the shape of the decrees, there is strong evidence that from about 1548 to 1602, except for the short period of Mary's reign, "the community, in cases of adultery, relied upon them as justifying a second act of matrimony."[240] For already in 1548--four years before Edward's commission had completed its report--the new doctrine had been in a measure sustained by the well-known case of Lord Northampton, brother of Queen Catherine Parr. After obtaining a decision of an ecclesiastical court separating him from his wife, Anne Bourchier, the marquis had contracted another union with Elizabeth Brooke, daughter of Lord Cobham. Subsequently a commission of delegates, headed by the archbishop of Canterbury, declared the second marriage valid, "because the former contract had been absolutely destroyed" by Anne Bourchier's infidelity;[241] and in 1552 this decision was confirmed by an act of Parliament[242] which declares the marriage valid "by the law of God,--any decretal, canon ecclesiastical, law, or usage to the contrary notwithstanding."[243]

A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Volume 2 (of 3) — Part 77

[Footnote 238: GEARY, _Marriage and Family Relations_, 8 n. 6.]

A History of Matrimonial Institutions, Volume 2 (of 3) — Part 77

[Footnote 239: So by Sir John Stoddart in his evidence before the Lords' Select Committee, 1844: "Therefore I apprehend that the _Reformatio legum_ having been published as a work of authority, although not of absolute legislative authority, it must have been, and in all probability was, followed: and for that reason _in the Spiritual Courts there were dissolutions of marriage_. Because _I believe that from about the year 1550 to the year 1602 marriage was not held by the Church, and therefore was not held by the Law, to be indissoluble_."--_Minutes of Evidence_, 27: _Law Review_ (Eng.), I, 358, 359.]