It cannot be denyed, but that the _Argument_ is very strong, and these reasons being considered by him of _Marchena_, have made him affirme, that _Chocolate_ is Obstructive; it seeming to be contrary to Philosophy, that in it there should be found _Heat_ and _Moysture_, _in gradu intenso_; and to be so likewise in _Cold_ and _Dry_.
To this, there are two things to be answered: One, that he never saw the experience of drawing out the Butter, which I have done; and that when the _Chocolate_ is made without adding any thing to the dryed Powder, which is incorporated, onely by beating it well together, and is united, and made into a Paste, which is a signe, that there is a moist, and glutinous part, which, of necessity, must correspond with the Element of Aire.
The other reason, we will draw from Philosophy; affirming that, in the _Cacao_, there are different substances. In the one, that is to say, in that, which is not so fat, it hath a greater quantity of the Oylie, then of the earthie Substance; and in the fatter part, it hath more of the earthy than of the Oily substance. In these there is Heate and Moysture in predominancy; and in the other, cold and dry.
Notwithstanding that it is hard to be believed, that in one and the same substance, and so little of the _Cacao_, it can have substances so different: To the end that it may appeare more easie, clear, and evident, first we see it in the _Rubarbe_, which hath in it hot and soluble parts, and parts which are Binding, Cold and Dry, which have a vertue to strengthen, binde, and stop the loosenesse of the Belly: I say also, that he that sees and considers the steele, so much of the nature of the earth, as being heavy, thick, cold, and dry; it seemes to be thought unproper for the curing of Opilations, but rather to be apt to encrease them; and yet it is given for a proper remedy against them.
This difficulty is cleared thus, that though it be true, that it hath much of the Earthy part; yet it hath also parts of Sulphur, and of quick silver, which doe open, and disopilate; neither doth it so, untill it be helped by Art, as it is ground, stirred, and made fine, in the preparing of it; the Sulphurous parts, and those of quick-silver, being thinne, active, and penetrative, they mingle, at the last with those parts, which are Earthy and astringent: Insomuch, that they being mingled after this manner one with another, we cannot now say, that the steele is astringent, but rather, that it is penetrative, attenuating and opening. Let us prove this Doctrine by Authorities; and let the first be from _Gallen_, _l. 3._ of the qualities of Simples, _c. 14._ Where, first of all he teacheth, that almost all those Medicines, which, to our sence, seeme to be _Simple_, are notwithstanding naturally _Compounded_, containing in themselves contrary qualities; and that is to say, a quality to expell, and to retaine; to incrassate, and attenuate; to rarifie, and to condense. Neither are we to wonder at it, it being understood, that in every fore-said Medicine, there is a quality to heat, and to coole; to moisten and to dry. And whatsoever Medicine it be, it hath in it, thick, and thinne parts; rare, and dense; soft, and hard. And in the fifteenth Chapter following, in the same Book, he puts an example of the Broth of a Cock, which moves the Belly; and the flesh hath the vertue to bind. He puts also the example of the _Aloes_, which if it be washt, looseth the Purgative vertue; or that which it hath, is but weake.