Whether the bankrupt was insolvent on August 4, 1898, when he paid the money to his brother, the defendant, and whether the latter had reasonable cause to believe that it was intended thereby to give a preference, are questions of fact, determined by the verdict of the jury, and not open to review view in this court. Hedrick v. Atchison, T. & S. F. R. Co. 167 U.S. 673, 677, 42 L. ed. 320, 322, 17 Sup. Ct. Rep. 922; E. Bement & Sons v. National Harrow Co. 186 U.S. 70, 83, 46 L. ed. 1058, 1064, 22 Sup. Ct. Rep. 747; Jenkins v. Neff, 186 U.S. 230, 46 L. ed. 1140, 22 Sup. Ct. Rep. 905, and cases cited in opinions. It is suggested that the trial court erred in admitting testimony of transactions between the brothers some six or seven months prior to the payment by the bankrupt to the defendant; that such transactions were too remote from the time of the preference to throw light on the question of knowledge. We think that the testimony, whether of much or little value, was competent, and that it was not error for the court to admit it. Clune v. United States, 159 U.S. 590-592, 40 L. ed. 269, 270, 16 Sup. Ct. Rep. 125.
We see no reason to doubt the propriety of allowing interest on the claim from the commencement of the action. Such commencement is itself a demand.
The principal contention, however, is that the state court erred in ruling that the sum of $767, loaned by the defendant to the bankrupt on August 8, could not be considered as a set-off. If appeared that four days after he had received the money paid to him in preference the defendant handed to the bankrupt $767, on the latter's request for money to pay his employees. There was no testimony tending to show what became of this money, whether it was used in paying employees, or whether the payments, if made, were for wages earned within three months before the date of the commencement of proceedings in bakruptcy. All that appeared was the fact of the loan and the expressed purpose thereof. Under these circumstances the court instructed the jury that the defendant had not established his claim to a set-off, as authorized by paragraph c of § 60. This presents a distinct question of law.
The trial court, and its views were approved by the superior court, held that the statute required not merely that the creditor in good faith gave the debtor credit without security, and that the money or property in fact passed to the debtor, and became a part of his estate, but also that it remained such until the time of the bankruptcy, and was transferred to the trustee; or, at least, that it was used in payment of preferred debts. In its opinion, on a motion for a new trial, it said:
'Evidence that the debtor got the money for another purpose certainly is not evidence that he turned it over to the trustee.
'The most that defendant can ask-and this we would probably hold-is that money shown to have been given and used to pay a preferred debt would entitle the defendant to a set-off.'
It will be noticed that the words used in paragraph c are not 'the bankrupt's estate,' but 'the debtor's estate.' 'Debtor' is also found in the preceding clause as descriptive of the one to whom the credit is given. While the same person is both debtor and bankrupt, first debtor and then bankrupt, the use of the former term is suggestive of the time of the transaction as well as the status of the recipient of the credit. The paragraph further provides that 'the amount of such new credit remaining unpaid at the time of the adjudication in bankruptcy may be set off.' It is the nonpayment, and not the fact that the property remains still a part of the debtor's estate, which entitles to a set-off. It would seem that if Congress intended that which the trial court held to be the meaning of the statute, it would have said 'which becomes a part of the bankrupt's estate' or 'which becomes and remains a part of the debtor's estate until the adjudication in bankruptcy.'