Mr. CURRIER. I could tell the notes on that sheet just as well as I could on the other. [Laughter.]
Mr. O'CONNELL. All I have to say then is that apparently music is not one of your many accomplishments. [Laughter.] Some of us can not read Sanskrit, nor Hebrew, nor Greek, perhaps, but that does not mean that we can not read at all, nor that such languages can not be read. There are many of us that do understand the ordinary diatonic notation of music, and many of us that do not. The fact that the vast majority of people can not read music does not prevent it from being a writing.
The CHAIRMAN. Do you contend that it is beyond the power of Congress to make that roll copyrightable?
Mr. O'CONNELL. My contention is, sir, that it is absolutely beyond the power of Congress to make that roll copyrightable.
Senator SMOOT. Are there people that can read that roll--that is, the same as Mr. Sousa can pick up that piece of music there [indicating] and read that music? In other words, every slit or cut or dash in that paper represents a note, does it not, just the same as the notes are differently represented upon the paper that Mr. Sousa exhibited--or a musical tone is represented?
Mr. O'CONNELL. It may be, but I do not think that there is a person, firm, or corporation in the United States or elsewhere to-day that can take that music roll and tell you what particular note any particular slit or dot or dash represents. If I am wrong, I want to be corrected.
Mr. CHANEY. It is a notation of tone, then?
Mr. O'CONNELL. It is simply by relation to what is called the tracker board. This roll goes over a tracker board in which there are little holes. Each hole in the tracker board is connected with a little tube which carries the air through a bellows and to a device which strikes a hammer. As this roll goes over the tracker board of the instrument, when it strikes a hole corresponding to any particular one of those slits there is an ingress of air, because there is a vacuum underneath. That little tube is connected with a hammer which strikes the note A, B, C, and so forth, whatever it might be. They are differently arranged in different rolls. The roll that will play in one instrument will not play in another; and you can see, gentlemen, that there is a different-sized roll, different-sized slits [exhibiting sample rolls] notwithstanding that they are both the same piece of music, composed by Mr. Sousa. [Laughter.]