Letter XL.

St. Ambrose begs Theodosius to listen to him, as he

cannot be silent without great risk to both. He points out that

Theodosius though God-fearing may be led astray, and points out that

his decision respecting the restoration of the Jewish synagogue is full

of peril, exposing the bishop to the danger of either acting against

the truth or of death. The case of Julian is referred to, and the

reasons given for the imperial rescript are met, especially by the plea

that the Jews had burnt many churches. St. Ambrose touches on the

temple of the Valentinians, whom he declares to be worse than heathen, and points out what a door would be opened to the calumnies of the Jews and a triumph over Christ Himself. The Emperor is lastly warned by the example of Maximus not to take the part of Jews or heretics, and is urged to clemency.

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume X/Selections from Letters/Letter XL

, Bishop, to the most

clement prince, and blessed Emperor, Theodosius the Augustus.

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume X/Selections from Letters/Letter XL

1. I am continually harassed by almost incessant

cares, most blessed Emperor, but I have never been in such anxiety as

at present, since I see that I must take heed that there be nothing

which may be ascribed to me savouring even of sacrilege. And so I

entreat you to listen with patience to what I say. For, if I am

unworthy to be heard by you, I am unworthy to offer for you, who have

been entrusted by you with your vows and prayers. Will you not

yourself hear him whom you wish to be heard for you? Will you not

hear him pleading his own cause whom you have heard for others? And do you not fear for your own decision, lest by thinking him unworthy to be heard by you, you make him unworthy to be heard for you?

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume X/Selections from Letters/Letter XL

2. But it is neither the part of an emperor

to refuse liberty of speech, nor of a priest not to say what he

thinks. For there is nothing in you emperors so popular and so

estimable as to appreciate freedom in those even who are in subjection

to you by military obedience. For this is the difference between

good and bad princes, that the good love liberty, the bad

slavery. And there is nothing in a priest so full of peril as

regards God, or so base in the opinion of men, as not freely to declare

what he thinks. For it is written: “I spoke of Thy

testimonies before kings, and was not ashamed;” and in another place: “Son of

man, I have set Thee a watchman unto the house of Israel, in

order,” it is said, “that if the righteous doth turn from

his righteousness, and commit iniquity, because thou hast not given him

warning,” that is, hast not told him what to guard against, “the memory of his righteousness shall not be retained, and I will require his blood at thine hand. But if thou warn the righteous that he sin not, and he doth not sin, the righteous shall surely live because thou hast warned him, and thou shalt deliver thy soul.”

3. I had rather then, O Emperor, have fellowship

with you in good than in evil, and therefore the silence of the priest

ought to displease your Clemency, and his freedom to please you. For you are involved in the risk of my silence, but are aided by the benefit of my freedom. I am not, then, officiously intruding in things where I ought not, nor interfering in the affairs of others. I am obeying the commands of God. And I do this first of all out of love for you, good-will toward you, and desire of preserving your well-doing. If I am not believed in this, or am forbidden to act on this feeling, I speak in very truth for fear of offending God. For if my peril would set you free, I would patiently offer myself for you, though not willingly, for I had rather that without my peril you might be acceptable to God and glorious. But if the guilt of silence and dissimulation on my part would both weigh me down and not set you free, I had

rather that you should think me too

importunate, than useless and base. Since it is written, as the

holy Apostle Paul says, whose teaching you cannot controvert: “Be instant, in season, out of season, reprove, entreat, rebuke with all patience and doctrine.”