The French constitution of 4 October 1958 was revised many times in its early years. Changes to this fundamental law have become more frequent since the 1990s, for two major reasons: public projects for institutional modernization adaptation to European Union and other international law.

Overview

Amendment procedures

Article 89

The revision of the Constitution under Article 89 of the Constitution:<ref>Article 89 of the Constitution, version in force since 25 July 2008 (translated)</ref>

Constitutional amendments under the French Fifth Republic

In its current form, article 89 and 42 state that "the plenary discussion of the draft constitutional amendment ... carries, on first reading to the first meeting, on the text submitted by the Government, and for further reading on the text sent by the other parliamentary branch" (and not on the text adopted by the committee as ordinary laws). Furthermore, "the discussion in meeting, first reading of a draft or a bill can only occur before the first assembly, until the expiration of a period of six weeks after filing. It can only occur before the second meeting at the expiration of a period of four weeks from the date of transmission."

Constitutional amendments under the French Fifth Republic

The Constitutional Council declared itself incompetent to rule on a constitutional revision.

Constitutional amendments under the French Fifth Republic

Other ways to amend

Since the beginning of the French Fifth Republic, revisions have been adopted without using section 89. The Constitutional Act of 4 June, 1960 was adopted by a parliamentary vote according to the original article 85 of the Constitution, which involved the Senate of the Community. The Constitutional Act of 6 November, 1962 was adopted, without any parliamentary procedure, through direct referendum by . Using this procedure to revise the Constitution this way has been strongly criticized, since the text of Article 11 does not explicitly provide that it can be used to revise the Constitution.

When amendments are effective

Unless otherwise stated, the provisions of constitutional laws come into force on the date of enactment.

However, some recent constitutional laws have provided a delayed effective date. The material content of the Constitution, in these cases, changes on different dates from those of other enactments of constitutional laws.

For example, the constitution act of 23 July 2008 provides in article 46 that some sections of the reform are effective on 1 March 2009 and others "under the conditions established by law and necessary for their implementing organic laws" (translated).Original: dans les conditions fixées par les lois et lois organiques nécessaires à leur application. Thus the old wording of certain articles remained in force for more than eighteen months after the constitutional amendment, while implementing laws were not all ready. This is notably the case of the establishment of referendums initiated by the parliament and supported by a part of the electorate, which is foreseen in the new version of Article 11.

The same constitutional amendment provides in Article 47 that certain amendments of the articles of the Constitution relating to the European Union come into force at the time Lisbon Treaty becomes effective. This occurred on 1 December 2009 and the new content of these articles came into force on that date.

The Constitutional Law of 1 March 2005 had planned similar provisions concerning entry into force of the Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe, which have become obsolete due to the termination of the process of ratification of this Treaty.

Adopted amendments

All amendments

The French Constitution of the Fifth Republic has been revised twenty-four different times since 1958:

1962: Election of the President of the Republic by direct universal suffrage

Wanting to override the likely opposition of the Senate, De Gaulle revised the constitution using Article 11, which allows the president to submit to referendum "any bill on the organization of government.''" The legality of using this method is very questionable, as the Constitution provides mechanisms for its own review in section 89 (a referendum is possible, but only with the agreement of the parliament). It aroused intense political debate and legal controversy, and the formation of a secret group of votes against (cartel des non).

However, the prestige of De Gaulle, the fact that the "yes" won with over 62% of the vote, and the fact that the Constitutional Council refuses to review the constitutionality of laws passed by referendum (as they are adopted by the people), allowed the implementation of this reform.