With these opinions, I cannot but look upon this threatened change of _checks_ into _ethics_, as wholly unwarrantable, and I now protest against it as earnestly as, upon a former occasion, I did against the alteration of _sickles_ into _shekels_, or, still worse, into _cycles_ or into _circles_. It is with great satisfaction I compare four different views taken of this word by MR. COLLIER, viz.--in the note to the text of his octavo edition of Shakspeare;--in an additional note in vol. i., page cclxxxiv. of that edition;--in the first announcement of his annotated folio in the _Athenæum_ newspaper, Jan. 31st, 1852,--and finally (after my remarks upon the word in "N. & Q."), his virtual reinstatement of the original _sickle_ (till then supposed a palpable and undeniable misprint) at page 46. of _Notes and Emendations_, together with the production, _suo motu_, of an independent reference in support of my position.

To return to this present substitution of _ethics_ for _checks_, a very singular circumstance connected with it is the ignoring, by both MR. COLLIER and by the critic in the _Gentleman's Magazine_, of Sir William Blackstone's original claim to the suggestion, by prior publication of upwards of half a century. At that time, notwithstanding the great learning and acuteness of the proposer, the alteration was rejected! And shall we now be less wise than our fathers? Shall we--misled by the prestige of a few drops of rusty ink fashioned into letters of formal cut--place implicit credence in emendations whose only claim to faith, like that of the Mormon scriptures, is that nobody knows whence they came? { 498}

Notes and Queries, Number 186, May 21, 1853 — Part 11

In the passage I have quoted from Philemon Holland, there may be observed two peculiarities which are generally supposed to be exclusively Shakspearian: one is the beautiful application of the word "touch"--the other the phrase "discourse of reason." Where this last expression occurs in _Hamlet_, it narrowly escaped _emendation_ at the hands of Gifford! (See Mr. Knight's note, in his illustrated edition of _Shakspeare_.) It is the true Aristotelian [Greek: dianoia].

Notes and Queries, Number 186, May 21, 1853 — Part 11

There is also a third peculiarity of expression in the same quotation, in the use of the word _delay_ in the sense of _diluere_, to dilute, temper, allay. There are at least two passages in Shakspeare's plays where the word is used in this sense, but which appear to have been overlooked by his glossarists. The first is in _All's Well that Ends Well_, Act IV. Sc. 3., where the French locals are moralising upon Bertram's profligate pursuit of Diana:

Notes and Queries, Number 186, May 21, 1853 — Part 11