(1) Concerning the generalization that “all birds have wings,” it becomes possible to observe in detail the nature of the wings and advance the hypothesis that these wings are designed for aërial navigation. This hypothesis may then be strengthened by observing that the entire structure of the bird is adapted to flying.

(2) If it were possible to analyze the atmosphere, water, and soil of Mars, and should such analysis reveal a composition similar to that of the earth, it would illustrate well not only the _method_ of analysis but also its superiority over the other methods of investigation.

A Class Room Logic — Part 207

(3) The physician, in diagnosing a “case,” observes that the symptoms resemble those of typhoid; but to be positive of the truth of his diagnosis, he takes a blood test. Noting the resemblances is induction by analogy; but the blood test involves induction by analysis.

A Class Room Logic — Part 207

Induction by analysis concerns hypothesis, observation, and experiment, including Mill’s experimental methods. These topics will receive due attention in the chapters which follow. It will be sufficient to close this discussion with a brief treatment of perfect induction, and traduction.

A Class Room Logic — Part 207

As has been indicated under simple enumeration, _a perfect induction is one in which the premises enumerate all the instances denoted by the conclusion_.

(1) A, B, C, D, and E are all Reactionaries, (All) The members of the committee are A, B, C, D, and E, ∴ (All) The members of the committee are Reactionaries.

(2) John, James, Albert, and Peter all have perfect eyesight, John, James, Albert, and Peter are all the boys of my family, ∴ All the boys of my family have perfect eyesight.

(3) The first, second, and third groups are up to grade, The first, second, and third groups include all of the children in my room, Hence all the children in my room are up to grade.

Because the conclusion of a perfect induction gives nothing new――nothing but what is found in the premises, some claim that the process is practically valueless. From the viewpoint of the discoverer this position is well taken; yet to universalize particular observations puts the knowledge in compact, usable form, and saves one the trouble of returning each time to the consideration of each particular. Thus as a process which leads to verified universals, perfect induction is a _time saver_. In the second place it was the method used by Socrates when he desired to lead up to a definition or some other general truth. The Sophists were given to a careless use of the “inductive hazard”; they were prone to generalize from one or two particulars, or what is worse, to establish a generalization and then attempt to fit the particular instances to it. This led to a superficiality which the Great Pagan Educator abhorred. The fact that perfect induction was the method used by Socrates to counteract the teachings of the Sophists, is sufficient vindication for its use in discouraging the indefensible assumptions of to-day, and in inspiring warrantable generalizations based on accurate observation.