The consensus 1958 College Basketball All-American team, as determined by aggregating the results of six major All-American teams. To earn "consensus" status, a player must win honors from a majority of the following teams: the Associated Press, the USBWA, The United Press International, the National Association of Basketball Coaches, the Newspaper Enterprise Association (NEA), and the International News Service.
1958 Consensus All-America team
Individual All-America teams
AP Honorable Mention:
Bucky Allen, Duke
Gene Brown, San Francisco
Leo Byrd, Marshall
Barney Cable, Bradley
Boo Ellis, Niagara
Wayne Embry, Miami (OH) Dom Flora, Washington and Lee Dave Gambee, Oregon State Hal Greer, Marshall Fred Grim, Arkansas Vernon Hatton, Kentucky Joe Hobbs, Florida Frank Howard, Ohio State Jack Kubiszyn, Alabama Red Murrell, Drake Jack Parr, Kansas State Hub Reed, Oklahoma City Earl Robinson, California Gary Simmons, Idaho Doug Smart, Washington Tony Windis, Wyoming