This is a suit in equity to compel the Merchants' Exchange National Bank of the City of New York, one of the defendants below, and the appellant here, to surrender to the board of chosen freeholders of the county of Bergen, New Jersey, 102 bonds of $500 each, drawn in the form of, and purporting to be, negotiable obligations of the board, on the ground that they were never issued by its authority. The suit was brought, not only against the bank which held the bonds, but also against the sheriff of the city and county of New York, who had previously levied an attachment upon them in an action brought by the bank against Benjamin C. Bogert, upon his alleged indebtedness to it of $51,000. The sheriff, having no interest in the controversy be-tween the board and the bank, made no contest and did not appear in the suit. The decree was, therefore, only against the bank.
The facts of the case are briefly these: The complainant below, the board of chosen freeholders of Bergen county, is a municipal corporation having general charge of the affairs of the county. It is composed of 13 representatives, one from each township of the county. Its officers are a director and a clerk elected by the board, the former from one of its own members. It also elects annually a collector, who acts as treasurer of the county, but is not a member or an officer of the board. It is his duty to collect the revenues of the county and to pay its expenses and liabilities. During the late civil war, bonds were issued by the board of chosen freeholders of Bergen county for money to enable it to raise and equip its quota of men under the different calls for tropps by the government. These bonds were about to mature, when the legislature, by an act passed on the fifth of April, 1876, authorized the boards of chosen freeholders of the several counties of the state to renew bonds previously issued by them for any loan made by them under authority of law, which should thereafter become due, and for which no provision should be made for their payment. The act required that the new bonds should be made payable within 30 years from date, and be so issued that 3 1/3 per cent. thereof should become due and payable each year; that they should draw interest not exceeding 7 per cent.; should bear the seal of the corporation; be signed by the director of the board and its clerk, and countersigned by the collector of the county, and have coupons attached to each one for the semi-annual interest, except that, when the board might judge it best, the bonds might be registered and be made payable to the order of the purchaser and issued without coupons. The act declared that all bonds issued under it should be numbered, and a register of the number, denomination, date of issuing, and name of person to whom issued, if registered, and time of payment, should be made by the collector in a book to be provided by the board for that purpose.