Letter CLXIV.
(a.d. 414.)
To My Lord Evodius Most Blessed, My
Brother and Partner in the Episcopal Office, Augustin Sends
Greeting in the Lord.
1. The question which you have proposed to me from
the epistle of the Apostle Peter is one which, as I think you are
aware, is wont to perplex me most seriously, namely, how the words
which you have quoted are to be understood on the supposition that
they were spoken concerning hell? I therefore refer this question
back to yourself, that if either you yourself be able, or can find
any other person who is able to do so, you may remove and terminate
my perplexities on the subject. If the Lord grant to me ability to
understand the words before you do, and it be in my power to impart
what I receive from Him to you, I will not withhold it from a
friend so truly loved. In the meantime, I will communicate to you
the things in the passage which occasion difficulty to me, that, keeping in view these remarks on the words of the apostle, you may either exercise your own thoughts on them, or consult any one whom you find competent to pronounce an opinion.
2. After having said that “Christ was put to
death in the flesh, and quickened in the spirit,” the apostle
immediately went on to say: “in which also He went and preached
unto the spirits in prison; which sometime were unbelieving, when once
the long-suffering of God waited in the days of Noah, while the ark
was a preparing, wherein few, that is, eight souls were saved by
water;” thereafter he added the words: “which baptism also now
by a like figure has saved you.” This, therefore, is felt by me to
be difficult. If the Lord when He died preached in hell to spirits
in prison, why were those who continued unbelieving while the ark
was a preparing the only ones counted worthy of this favour, namely, the Lord’s descending into hell? For in the ages between the time of Noah and the passion of Christ, there died many thousands of so many nations whom He might have found in hell. I do not, of course, speak here of those who in that period of time had believed in God, as, e.g. the prophets and patriarchs of Abraham’s line, or, going farther back, Noah himself and his house, who had been saved by water (excepting perhaps the one son, who afterwards was rejected), and, in addition to these, all others outside of the posterity of Jacob who were believers in God, such as Job, the citizens of Nineveh, and any others, whether mentioned in Scripture or existing unknown to us in the vast human family at any time. I speak only of those many thousands of men who, ignorant of God and devoted to the worship of devils or of idols, had passed out of this life from the time of Noah to the passion of Christ. How was it that Christ, finding these in hell, did not preach to them, but preached only to those who were unbelieving in the days of Noah when the ark was a preparing? Or if he preached to all, why has Peter mentioned only these, and passed over the innumerable multitude of others?
Chap. II.
3.—It is established beyond question that the
Lord, after He had been put to death in the flesh, “descended
into hell;” for it is impossible to gainsay either that utterance
of prophecy, “Thou wilt not leave my soul in
hell,”—an utterance which Peter himself
expounds in the Acts of the Apostles, lest any one should venture
to put upon it another interpretation,—or the words of the same
apostle, in which he affirms that the Lord “loosed the pains of
hell, in which it was not possible for Him to be holden.” Who, therefore, except an infidel, will deny that Christ was in hell? As to the difficulty which is found in reconciling the statement that the pains of hell were loosed by Him, with the fact that He had never begun to be in these pains as in bonds, and did not so loose them as if He had broken off chains by which He had been bound, this is easily removed when we understand that they were loosed in the same way as the snares of huntsmen may be loosed to prevent their holding, not because they have taken hold. It may also be understood as teaching us to believe Him to have loosed those pains which could not possibly hold Him, but which were holding those to whom He had resolved to grant deliverance.