"Chapter Three: Make the Unsafe Choice" is the third episode of the first season of the American dark comedy crime television series Barry. The episode was written by Duffy Boudreau, and directed by series co-creator Bill Hader, who also serves as the main lead actor. It was first broadcast on HBO in the United States on April 8, 2018.
The series follows Barry Berkman, a hitman from Cleveland who travels to Los Angeles to kill someone but finds himself joining an acting class taught by Gene Cousineau, where he meets aspiring actress Sally Reed and begins to question his path in life as he deals with his criminal associates such as Monroe Fuches and NoHo Hank. In the episode, Barry is instructed to kill a target for Pazar but is forced to delay the action per Hank's orders. His class is also the subject of a police investigation, as authorities found a connection between Ryan and the class. Sally has an audition, but meeting a former friend causes her to break down.
According to Nielsen Media Research, the episode was seen by an estimated 0.595 million household viewers and gained a 0.2 ratings share among adults aged 18–49. The episode received positive reviews from critics, who praised the performances, dark humor and character development.
Plot
Barry (Bill Hader) is surveilling the house of his new target, Paco, ready to kill him from a distance. However, Hank (Anthony Carrigan) calls him to delay the murder, as he wants to send the Bolivians a bullet through the mail just as they are informed of Paco's death. Despite risking his cover, Barry is forced to comply as Fuches (Stephen Root) is still hostage.
While working as a party princess, Sally (Sarah Goldberg) is informed by her agent that there is an audition for a We Bought a Zoo television adaptation, where Sally could play an extra. Pazar (Glenn Fleshler) informs Hank that they will get a new assassin, Stovka, and they are excited given his track record. Stovka (Larry Hankin), an old man who barely moves, arrives to stand guard on the garage where Fuches is held. Pazar instructs Stovka to kill both Barry and Fuches when Barry returns, panicking Fuches, who overheard the conversation.
Detective Moss (Paula Newsome) is informed by her partner, Detective Loach (John Pirruccello) that Ryan Madison had an affair with Pazar's wife, linking him to the murder but they still question who killed the Chechens at the crime scene. They deduce that because Ryan was unfamiliar with the city, he must have been with a member from his acting class. They decide to go to the class and question Gene (Henry Winkler) and his students. Meanwhile, a desperate Fuches attempts to talk Stovka out of killing him and Stovka reveals his unhappiness following his wife and child abandoning him. Stovka then kills himself with the gun, shocking Fuches and Pazar.
The detectives interrogate all students separately to find their connection to Ryan. During the interrogation, Gene uses the opportunity to flirt with Moss, who does not seem interested in him. Sally asks for Barry to help her get to her audition and he agrees, despite knowing the bullet's arrival could interfere with this. At her audition, Sally finds that a former friend, Liv (Kat Foster), is also auditioning. They previously worked in a failed series named Bonnie and the Boston Bombers. Sally is speechless when Liv reveals that she is playing the lead of the series and was the one who advocated for her audition. During her audition, Sally is so devastated by the event that she breaks down. Fuches dines with Pazar, where they both seem to bond over their possible actions against the Bolivian Mafia. Fuches suggests that Pazar could lure Cristobal Sifuentes, the leader of the Bolivians, to Los Angeles by taking one of his houses and then he could kill him, which seems to intrigue Pazar.
The bullet is finally delivered and Barry is told by Hank to finally go and kill Paco. However, Sally leaves her audition, devastated. She wants to be with Barry for comfort, but Barry tells her he needs to go. That night, he struggles in killing Paco from a distance as Sally keeps calling him. Eventually, Barry tells her he will go to be with her and decides to kill Paco in his house. Paco attempts to flee but Barry tackles him outside and then strangles him to death. He arrives at her house, where she wonders what her acting future will be and then they kiss. Barry then imagines a life where he and Sally shop together, before cutting to the present, where they both had sex. He remembers Paco's last words (which were said in Spanish) and asks Sally what it means. She says "you don't have to do this".