Unter sich standen die freien, ausser dem familienband, in einer festen gemeindeverbindung, in gesammtbtirgschaft und rechtsgenossenschaft. Nur in der gemeinde hatte der freie recht und frieden, zu welcher er als genosse gehorte.—Grimm's R. A. 1854, p. 291.
N the Duke of Norfolk's office in Sheffield are various plans made in the last century which delineate property in Sheffield. In examining them I was struck with the way in which pieces of land called "town lands" are intermixed with other property in the old parts of the town, for example in and near Waingate, Broad lane, Carver street, Balm green, and King street. And I noticed that a piece of land called "the Isle," at the foot of Lady's Bridge, is described as the property of "The Burgesses and Free Tenants of Sheffield." To one possessing an acquaintance with the origin and development of village communities an inspection of these plans would at once suggest that these "town lands" are pieces of land which were set apart in very early times by a community of freeholders for the public benefit of the "town," meaning the whole body of freeholders.
The "town lands" of Sheffield are now vested in a body known by the modern name of "Town Trustees," and it will be the object of this chapter to exhibit the true origin of their "trust," and the purposes to which the lands of the "trust" were originally applied.
It will be best to trace the history of the "Town Trust" backwards, as one would trace a pedigree.
Soon after the Civil Wars doubts were entertained by the then lessees of the "town lands" as to the title of the persons who granted their leases. The leases, it appears, had been granted by a number of persons who called themselves "The Burghers or major part of the Burghers of Sheffield," and sometimes by the name of "The Burghers or major part of the Burghers and Free Tenants of Sheffield," and "by various names and descriptions." These doubts at length culminated in the refusal of the tenants, seventy-nine in number, to pay rent, and in an attempt to retain the lands leased or demised by the Burghers as their own estates in fee simple. But this attempt was hardly serious, and both tenants and lessors became in the end willing that the demised lands should be made subject to a declaration of trust for various public uses. They saw no doubt that it was just that the rents should be applied, as in past times, to the public service of the town. The real and only difficulty was that the estates seemed to have no definite legal owners, and, as they belonged to the whole body of freeholders or burgesses, it was desirable that a vesting order should be made, so that a given number of freeholders might act in the name of the whole, and be duly appointed for that purpose by the freeholders. Accordingly an application was made to the Court of Chancery, and, notice having been served upon all parties interested, a decree was made in the year 1681, which for the first time appeared to bring these lands within the description of a charity. "The property," says Hunter, "has been accumulated by the benefactions of various individuals, amongst whom it is probable were the Furnivals, and particularly that Thomas Furnival who gave the town its charter. The gifts were made by them not exactly for the purposes to which we apply the term charitable, but rather for public uses." Hunter does not, however, give a single instance of any grant or donation to the Burgesses. As I shall presently show the "town lands" were never treated as a charity until the Court of Chancery in 1681 impressed them with the appearance of a charity. I say impressed them with the appearance of a charity because, notwithstanding the decree of charitable uses, the "town lands" are not held on charitable uses now, though recent gifts, such as the Bailey bequest, may be regarded as such. It may well have been that in 1681 the origin and nature of these "town lands" had been utterly forgotten. Nor had the history and development of village communities and municipal corporations been investigated in Hunter's time. It was almost inevitable therefore that he should treat the property as a charity, though he does so with caution and diffidence. Mr. Leader who had copied large portions of the accounts and minutes of this ancient guild was the first to draw public attention to its true nature and objects.