This was an amended bill of complaint filed November 30, 1895, in the circuit court of the United States for the southern district of Florida by Charles M. Furman in his own right, and as administrator of the estate of Charles M. Furman; Bolivar B. Furman, and Alester G. Furman, all citizens of the state of South Carolina, against Henry L. Mitchell, governor, William D. Bloxham, comptroller, Charles B. Collins, treasurer, William B. Lamar, attorney general, and Lucius B. Wombwell, commissioner of agriculture, of the state of Florida, and citizens thereof, as the board of trustees of the internal improvement fund of the state of Florida; the Florida Coast Line Canal & Transportation Company, a corporation of Florida, having its principal place of business at St. Augustine; the St. Johns Railway way Company, a corporation of Florida, having its principal place of business at Jacksonville; Horace S.C.ummings, residing in the District of Columbia; and John A. Henderson, a citizen of the state of Florida, alleging: 'That they own and hold title in fee simple, as tenants in common, to all that tract, parcel, or piece of land lying, situate, and being in the county of St. Johns in the state of Florida, and within townships 7, 8, and 9, south of range 30 east, known as 'Anastasia,' or 'St. Anastasia,' Island, said to contain 10,000 acres, but which in fact contains about 7,500 acres, excepting therefrom what was known at the time of the Spanish grant hereinafter mentioned as the King's Quarries, the boundaries of which were marked by stakes, the same being about 200 acres, lying on and east of the old King's Road, between the same and the old lighthouse, which exception does not embrace the lands or any part thereof hereinafter alleged to be claimed by the defendants or any of them.'

'That the said tract of land was granted by the government of Spain to Jos e, or Joseph, Fish-otherwise known as Jesse Fish (hereinafter designated as Joseph Fish), on or about the 19th day of June, A. D. 1795, which said grant was ratified and confirmed by the United States by the treaty with Spain ratified by the United States on the 19th day of February, A. D. 1821.'

Mitchell v. Furman/Opinion of the Court

The bill then set up title to Anastasia island as derived from Joseph Fish, through his mother Sarah Fish, her granddaughter, Jessie B. Perpall, who married Charles M. Furman, who became sole heir at law of his wife and their son, Gabriel, and left a will under which complainants claimed. It was averred that Joseph Fish died intestate in 1798; that his mother died intestate in 1825; that her granddaughter died intestate in 1827; that Mrs. Furman's son Gabriel died in infancy in 1836; and that Charles M. Furman died in 1872.

Mitchell v. Furman/Opinion of the Court

It was further alleged that Joseph Fish was placed in possession of the said land so granted, and resided thereon in his dwelling house, and cultivated an orange grove and fields, inclosed by a fence; that he used the woodlands on the island, and exercised such acts of possession of the whole of the island as it was capable of; and that from his death to the present time those claiming under Fish have done the same.

Mitchell v. Furman/Opinion of the Court

The bill averred that the state of Florida claimed title under the act of Congress of September 28, 1850, relating to swamp lands, of certain lands on Anastasia island, which complainants asserted were part of the grant to Joseph Fish, and owned by them; these were described according to the public surveys and alleged to contain 1,465.15 acres, more or less, all in township 7, south of range 30 east; and that the United States on September 18, 1856, issued its patent to the state of Florida therefor.

That the state of Florida by an act of June 6, 1855, vested in the governor, the comptroller, the state treasurer, the attorney general, and the register of public lands, now known as the commissioner of agriculture, of that state, and their successors in office, as the board of trustees of the internal improvement fund of the state, the title to all lands granted to the state under the act of Congress, with power to sell and transfer the same; that defendants, Mitchell, governor, and others, now constitute the board of trustees; that the board on May 13, 1885, executed a deed of conveyance to the Florida Coast Line Canal & Transportation Company of certain lots and parts of sections, in township 7, containing in all 549 acres, which land, except that conveyed to Horace S.C.ummings, was claimed by the transportation company adversely to complainants; that of these lands the transportation company executed a deed of conveyance to Cummings of 160 acres, which was claimed by Cummings adversely to complainants.