Of the results or operations of the faculty under consideration, we have considered, as yet, only that class which may be designated as primary _truths_, in distinction from primitive or intuitive _conceptions_. To this latter class let us now direct our attention.

_Proposed consideration of some of the more important._--Without undertaking to give a complete list of our original or intuitive conceptions, there are certain of the more important, which seem to require specific consideration. Such are the ideas of space, time, identity, cause, the beautiful, the right--ideas difficult to define and explain, but, on that account, requiring the more careful investigation. Let us, then, take up these conceptions one by one, and inquire more particularly into their nature.

Mental Philosophy: Including the Intellect, Sensibilities, and Will — Part 161

_Subjective View._--What is space? Is it a mere idea, a mere conception of the mind, or has it reality? This is a question which has much perplexed philosophers. Kant and his school regard both time and space as merely subjective, mere conceptions or forms which the mind imposes upon outward things, having no reality, save as conceptions, or laws of thought.

Mental Philosophy: Including the Intellect, Sensibilities, and Will — Part 161

_Opposite View._--On the other hand, if we make space a reality, and not a mere conception, what is it, and where is it? Not matter, and yet real, a something which exists, distinct from matter, and yet not mind. Pressed with these difficulties, some distinguished and acute writers have resolved time and space into qualities of the one infinite and absolute Being, the divine mind. Such was the view of Clarke and Newton, a view favored also by a recent French writer of some note--C. H. Bernard, Professor of Philosophy in the Lycée Bonaparte.

Mental Philosophy: Including the Intellect, Sensibilities, and Will — Part 161

_A middle Ground._--These must be regarded as, on either hand, extreme views. But is there a middle ground possible or conceivable? Let us see. What, then, is the simple idea of space? What mean we by that word?

_Idea of Space._--When we contemplate any material object, any existence of which the senses can take cognizance, we are cognizant of it as _extended_, _i. e._, _occupying space_, nor can we possibly conceive of it as otherwise. The idea of space, then, is involved in the very idea of extended substance, or material existence, given along with it, impossible to be separated from it. We may regard it, therefore, as _the condition or postulate of being, considered as material existence, possessing extension_, etc. The idea of it is essential to the idea of matter, the reality of it to the reality of matter; for if there were no space, there could be no extension in space, and, without extension, no matter.