“There are some cases wherein a vegetable and milk diet seems absolutely necessary, as in severe and habitual gouts, rheumatisms, cancerous, leprous, and scrofulous disorders; extreme nervous colics, epilepsies, violent hysteric fits, melancholy, consumptions (and the like disorders, mentioned in the preface), and towards the last stages of all chronic distempers. In such distempers _I have seldom seen such a diet fail of a good effect at last_.”
Six years later, in 1740, appeared his _Essay on Regimen: together with Five Discourses Medical Moral and Philosophical, &c._ Since his last exhortation to the world Cheyne had evidently convinced himself, by long experience as well as reflection, of the great superiority of the vegetable diet for all--sound as well as sick; and, accordingly, he speaks in strong and clear language of the importance of a general reform. As a consequence of this plain speaking, his new book met with a comparatively cold reception. Perhaps, too, its mathematical and somewhat abstruse tone may have affected its popularity. As regards its moral tone it was a new revelation, doubtless, for the vast majority of his readers. He boldly asserts:--
“The question I design to treat of here is, whether animal or vegetable food was, in the original design of the Creator, intended for the food of animals, and particularly of the human race. And I am almost convinced it _never was intended, but only permitted as a curse or punishment_.... At what time animal [flesh] food came first in use is not certainly known. He was a bold man who made the first experiment.
_Illi robur et æs triplex Circa pectus erat._
To see the convulsions, agonies, and tortures of a poor fellow-creature, whom they cannot restore nor recompense, dying to gratify luxury, and tickle callous and rank organs, must require a rocky heart, and a great degree of cruelty and ferocity. I cannot find any great difference, _on the foot of natural reason and equity only, between feeding on human flesh and feeding on brute animal flesh, except custom and example_.
I believe some [more] rational creatures would suffer less in being fairly butchered than a strong Ox or red Deer; and, in natural morality and justice, the _degrees of pain_ here make the essential difference, for as to other differences, _they are relative only_, and can be of no influence with an infinitely perfect Being. Did not use and example weaken this lesson, and make the difference, reason alone could never do it.”--_Essay on Regimen, &c._ 8vo. 1740. Pages 54 and 70.