This may seem an over fine analysis of one story but it will help us in judging other child stories having a regard to their memory value for the child.
Almost, if not more important a consideration than the writing of a drama, is the matter of the stage “business” in its successful production. The manager must decide which movements of his actors, which exits and entrances, which stage arrangement, lighting and what scheme of costuming will strengthen the salient idea underlying the plot of the drama and make it a _memory_ in the minds of the audience. Stage “business” is a matter of psychology. It means that the stage manager, the playwright or whoever knows the audience best is going to plan a mechanical background, a hedge, a wall, of associates that will make the audience remember the play. A good story should have “business,” the necessary costuming and lighting.
How shall the story teller apply this memory test in her selection of stories? How shall she be able to say with authority:
“My children will not forget this story!”
In the first place we should assure ourselves to our complete satisfaction in selecting a story that it _has a theme_, a _motif_ upon which we can build the chords of a complete melody. It is doubtful if the story of “The Greedy Cat” has a sufficient theme to make it of value as a memory story, although it has a very real place in the child’s life as a relaxing bit of nonsense. “The Little Pine Tree That Wished New Leaves” has a well defined theme--that of _contentment_.
The second question that we will ask ourselves will be, _is this story theme a worth while one for us to give the children as a permanent part of their mental lives?_ We would hardly wish a child to remember always about the greed of the gormandizing cat. We would be glad to have him hang up in his mind house a picture of content as illustrated by the little green tree that discovered his own leaves to be better than any others.
Last, we will ask, _is the story theme so compellingly associated with other ideas that it will become a memory for the child?_ In the case of the story of the Little Pine Tree, this treatment is carefully adhered to. Never is the _leaf_ idea lost. Instead, the idea is presented in the form of gold leaves, leaves of glass, in fact all the strange and different leaves for which the discontented tree wished. But the gold leaves are stolen by a miser; the glass leaves are broken in a storm, and its juicy large leaves are all eaten by a goat. The climax is reached when the little tree is glad to have back its slender green needles; and the story is fixed in a child’s mind because of its associative treatment.