Were the appellants entitled, of right, to bring this case here from the circuit court of appeals? Has a clerk of a circuit court of the United States authority to receive money brought into court by a private suitor, and is he responsible upon his bond if he does not deposit it as required by statute and appropriates it to his own use? Is the bond of the clerk for the protection of private suitors, as well as of the United States? Has a private suitor the right, without express statutory authority, to sue on the bond of the clerk in the name of the United States for his benefit?
These questions are presented by the record, and will be examined after we shall have stated the facts set out in the special findings made by the circuit court.
On the 3d day of March, 1887, Warren Watson was duly appointed clerk of the circuit court of the United States for the western division of the western district of Missouri; and on the same day he executed, and the court approved, his bond to the United States in the penalty of $20,000.
He died March 24th, 1892, while acting as clerk, and an administrator of his estate was appointed April 2d, 1892. Notices, as required by the local law, having been previously given for the presentation of claims, the administration of the estate was closed and the administrator discharged on the 11th day of September, 1894. At no time did the United States or the relator, Stewart, exhibit or present any claim against Watson's estate.
Stewart instituted, February 6th, 1891, in the circuit court of the United States, a suit at law against Henry county, Missouri, upon three bonds of the county, two for $1,000 each and one for $500. His petition contained three counts. In the first count he asked for judgment for $1,010, with interest from September 1st, 1887, as the amount due on the first bond of $1,000. The second count was upon the other bond for $1,000; the third, upon the $500 bond.
On the 3d day of March, 1891, the county filed its answer alleging as to the first count that on September 6th [1st], 1887, there was due on the bond therein referred to $1,010, and on that date it had deposited that sum in the National Bank of Commerce of New York for the payment of the bond and interest, and tendered the same to the plaintiff as full payment thereof, but that the plaintiff had refused to accept such payment. The answer further alleged that the defendant had 'at all times been ready and willing to pay plaintiff said sum of $1,010 in full payment of said bond and unpaid interest, and now here again tenders to plaintiff said sum of $1,010 in full payment of said bond and unpaid interest due thereon, on September 6th [1st], 1887, and now brings the said sum into court.' The answer to the second and third counts was exactly the same, except that as to the third count the amount named was $505, instead of $1,010.
On the same day, March 3d, 1891, there was entered on the records of the court in said cause the following order: 'This day comes defendant by its attorney and files answer and tenders to the plaintiff and deposits with the clerk the sum of $2,525 in payment and satisfaction of his cause of action in the petition set forth. Thereupon a stipulation waiving a trial by jury is filed herein.'
It was found as a fact that Henry county did hand to Watson the sum of $2,525 as recited in that order.
On June 27th, 1891, Stewart, the plaintiff in that suit, filed a reply, which was a general denial of the facts alleged in the answer.
On July 2d, 1894, more than two years after Watson's death, there was entered on the records of the court in the cause the following: 'This day come the parties by their attorneys, the plaintiff by Karnes, Holmes, & Krauthoff, and the defendant by M. A. Fyke, and a stipulation waiving a jury having been heretofore filed herein, the hearing of this cause is proceeded with before the court. Thereupon evidence is heard and the case is submitted to the court and by the court taken under advisement, with leave to the parties to file briefs.'