And so to return to the case of the _Comédie-Française_. In December, 1775, being for a short time in Paris, Beaumarchais addressed himself to the comedians, in a letter the tone and matter of which show that his solicitude as an author had been aroused by a suspicion that they were trying to make his piece _tomber dans les règles_, and so confiscate it, by giving it on a day when some special performance at Versailles was liable to attract thither a large portion of the theater-going public. He wrote in a spirited way demanding that something be substituted for the _Barbier_ on that night. The letter terminates thus, "All the good days except Saturday, the 23rd of December, 1775, you will give me the greatest pleasure to satisfy with the _Barbier_, the small number of its admirers. For that day only, it will be easy to admit the validity of my excuses, recognized by the _Comédie_ itself. I have the honor to be, etc.
"In re-reading my letter I reflect that the _Comédie_ may be embarrassed for Saturday because all the great tragedians are at Versailles. If that is the reason--Why did you not tell me simply how the matter stood? He who seems strict and rigorous in discussing his affairs is often the man who is the easiest in obliging his friends.--I should be distressed if the _Comédie_ had the smallest occasion to complain of me, as I hope always to have nothing but praise for it.
"Reply if you please. Paris, December 20th 1775."
Time passed on. As Beaumarchais had given to the comedians his first two dramas, hope was entertained that he would demand no return for his _Barbier_. Early in May, 1776, to their surprise and dismay, came a polite request that an exact account of the part due him as the author be made out and given to him. The play then had been given thirty-two times.
Not wishing to stir up trouble between themselves and their excellent friend, while at the same time unable and unwilling to grant the request, the comedians met the difficulty by a profound silence. "At last," says Beaumarchais in his _Compte rendu_, written several years later, "one of them asked me if it was my intention to give the piece to the _Comédie_ or to require the right of authorship? I replied laughing like Sagnarelle: 'I will give it, if I wish to give it, and I will not give it, if I do not wish to give it; which does not in the least interfere with my receiving the account; a present has no merit, excepting as he who gives knows its value.'