Given a graph $G$, its Hall ratio $\rho(G)=\max_{ H\subseteq G}\frac{ |V(H)|}{ \alpha(H)}$ forms a natural lower bound on its fractional chromatic number $\chi_f(G)$. A recent line of research studied the fundamental question of whether $\chi_f(G)$ can be bounded in terms of a (linear) function of $\rho(G)$. In a breakthrough-result, Dvo\v{ r}\'{ a}k, Ossona de Mendez and Wu gave a strong negative answer by proving the existence of graphs with bounded Hall ratio and arbitrarily large fractional chromatic number. In this paper, we solve two natural follow-up problems that were raised by Dvo\v{ r}\'{ a}k et al. The first problem concerns determining the growth of $g(n)$, defined as the maximum ratio $\frac{ \chi_f(G)}{ \rho(G)}$ among all $n$-vertex graphs. Dvo\v{ r}\'{ a}k et al. obtained the bounds $\Omega(\log\log n) \le g(n)\le O(\log n)$, leaving an exponential gap between the lower and upper bound. We almost fully resolve this problem by proving that the truth is close to the upper bound, i.e., $g(n)=(\log n)^{ 1-o(1)}$. The second problem posed by Dvo\v{ r}\'{ a}k et al. asks for the existence of graphs with bounded Hall ratio, arbitrarily large fractional chromatic number and such that every subgraph contains an independent set that touches a constant fraction of its edges. We affirmatively solve this second problem by showing that such graphs indeed exist.
Categories: math.CO