[Illustration: FIG. 4. Case of complete syndactyly in the foot. _II_ and _III_, digit apparently representing the index and medius. _c_^{ 2} + _c_^{ 3}, bone apparently representing the middle and external cuneiform; _cb_, cuboid; _c_^{ 1}, internal cuneiform. (After Gruber.)]

Webbing between the digits, in at least some of its manifestations, is a variation of similar nature. The family recorded by Newsholme[12] very clearly shows the dominance of this condition. The case is morphologically of great interest and must undoubtedly have a bearing on the problems of the mechanics of Division. In discussing the phenomena of syndactylism I pointed out some years ago that the digits most frequently united in the human hand are III and IV, while in the foot, union most frequently takes place between II and III.[13] In Newsholme's family the union was always between II and III of the foot, except in the case of one male who had the digits III and IV of the right _hand_ alone webbed together. There can be little doubt that the geometrical system on which the foot is planned has an axis of symmetry passing between the digits II and III, while the corresponding axis in the hand passes between III and IV. Union between such digits may therefore be regarded as comparable with any non-division or "coalescence" of lateral structures in a middle line, and when as in these examples such a condition is shown to be a dominant we cannot avoid the inference that some concrete factor has the power of suppressing or inhibiting this division. Figs. 3 and 4 illustrate degrees of union between digits in the human hand and foot.

Problems of Genetics — Part 38

It is not in question that various other forms of irregular webbing and coalescence of digits exist, and respecting the genetic behaviour of these practically nothing is as yet known. Such a case is described by Walker,[14] in which the first and second metacarpals of both feet were fused in mother and daughter, and several more are found in literature. Contrasted with these phenomena we have the curious fact that in the Pigeon, Staples-Browne found webbing of the toes a _recessive_ character. The question thus arises whether this webbing is of the same nature as that shown to be a dominant in Man, and indeed whether the phenomenon in pigeons is really meristic at all. There is some difference perceptible between the two conditions; for in Man there is not so much a development of a special web-like skin uniting the digits as a want of proper division between the digits themselves, and in extreme cases two digits may be represented by a single one. In the Pigeon I am not aware that a real union of this kind has ever been observed, and though the web-like skin may extend the whole length of the digits and be so narrow as to prevent the spread of the toes, it may, I think, be maintained that the unity of the digits is unimpaired. For the present the nature of this variation in the pigeon's feet must be regarded as doubtful, and we should note that if it is actually an example of a more perfect division being dominant to a less perfect division, the case is a marked exception to the general rule that non-division is dominant to division.

Problems of Genetics — Part 38