THE MAYOR'S ARGUMENTS AGAINST NICOLL CONTROVERTED BY HIS OWN POLITICAL COURSE IN THE PAST.

The Hon. Carl Schurz last evening

addressed the following open letter to Mayor

Hewitt in reply to his letter to the Harlem

Democratic Club:

The New York Times/Answering Mayor Hewitt

Permit me to introduce myself to you as one of a large

number of citizens who, without regard to your party

affiliations, supported you when you were a candidate for

the mayor's office. At the instance of some of them for

whom I then spoke, I address you now.

The New York Times/Answering Mayor Hewitt

In saying this I do not lay claim to extraordinary

consideration. I mention it only in order to remind you

of the fact that the ground upon which the independent

citizens supported you was well understood. We believed

that as mayor of this great city you would infuse an

element of superior intelligence and honor into the

conduct of our municipal affairs, and, by the force of your

example as well as by the legitimate use of your influence, endeavor to emancipate them from the rule of that narrow-minded, selfish and not infrequently corrupt partisanship from which the community has in the past suffered so much injury and disgrace. You cannot fail to remember how you encouraged that belief.

The New York Times/Answering Mayor Hewitt

No just man will deny that many of your acts have

deserved and obtained the applause of your fellow-citizens. So much the more is it to be deplored that now you have taken a step which, in its evil effects, threatens to outweigh all the good you have done or may do during the rest of your official term; and here I express not only my own, but the opinions, as far as I know, of all those who supported you without being moved by partisan motives.

The contest for the District Attorneyship has at this

time assumed unusual importance — not on account of

personal or party considerations, but because it involves

great public interests. The corruption so long prevailing

in our municipal affairs has seriously injured the welfare

as well as the good name of this community. A vigorous

prosecution of the thieves and betrayers of public trusts, of bribe-givers and bribe-takers, was felt to be the first step necessary if the public interest was to be protected and the disgrace wiped out. When at last that vigorous

prosecution took place it was hailed by all good citizens

as the breaking of a better day. Everybody knew that

it was owing mainly to Mr. Martine, who controlled the

operations of the district attorney's office, and to Mr. Nicoll, who worked up and conducted the trial of the “boodle” cases. This was so generally understood that when Mr. Martine desired a place on the bench, as was proper enough, Mr. Nicoll was almost universally looked upon as his natural successor. There was a general feeling that he had managed the prosecution not only with skill and untiring energy, but also with that firmness against adverse pressure, that fearlessness of the power of those he had to bring to justice and of their friends, which are especially indispensable under such circumstances. And since the district attorney's office appeared as the soul of the prosecutions, as the principal protector of the public interest and honor, Mr. Nicoll, who had done so well in the past, was regarded as especially trustworthy for the future — in fact, as the special representative of the vigor of the law.

That ordinary political hucksters who derive their

sustenance from selfish combinations should have opposed

him was not surprising. But nobody reckoned you

among that class. You are a man of recognized ability

and high social standing. You have the prestige of a

distinguished public career, and, as the head of this great

municipality, of important official position. Many a time

you have given the people to understand that you regarded

public office as a public trust. When you oppose what

is generally looked upon as demanded by the public

voice as well as the public interest, it must be expected

that you have weighty reasons for it — reasons

corresponding with your character and station.

You have given us those reasons in a letter addressed

to the Harlem Democratic club, and pardon me for saying

that to many of your friends they have been a painful

surprise.