In sociology of scientific knowledge, Planck's principle is the view that scientific change does not occur because individual scientists change their mind, but rather that successive generations of scientists have different views.

Formulation

This was formulated by Max Planck:

Planck's principle

Colloquially, this is often paraphrased as "Science progresses one funeral at a time".

Planck's principle

Adoption

Planck's quote has been used by Thomas Kuhn, Paul Feyerabend, Moran Cerf and others to argue scientific revolutions are non-rational, rather than spread through "mere force of truth and fact".

Planck's principle

Rebuttal

Whether age influences the readiness to accept new ideas has been empirically criticised. In the case of acceptance of evolution in the years after Darwin's On the Origin of Species, age was a minor factor. On a more specialized scale, it also was a weak factor in accepting cliometrics. A study of when different geologists accepted plate tectonics found that older scientists actually adopted it sooner than younger scientists. However, a more recent study on life science researchers found that following the deaths of preeminent researchers, publications by their collaborators rapidly declined while the activity of non-collaborators and the number of new researchers entering their field rose.

References

Principle

Concepts in epistemology

Epistemology of science

Historiography of science

Philosophy of science

Principles

Scientific revolution

Sociology of scientific knowledge

Cognitive inertia