The New York Mutuals baseball club, established 1859, played five seasons in the National Association, 1871–1875, and one in the National League, 1876. Here is a list of all their players in regular season games beginning 1871.

† Bold names identify members of the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

New York Mutuals all-time roster

A

Doug Allison

B

Billy Barnie

George Bechtel

Steve Bellán

Eddie Booth

Bill Boyd

Jack Burdock

C

Tom Carey

Bill Craver

Candy Cummings†

D

E

Dave Eggler

F

George Fair

Bob Ferguson

Frank Fleet

Davy Force

Chick Fulmer

G

Count Gedney

Billy Geer

Joe Gerhardt

H

Jimmy Hallinan

John Hatfield

John Hayes

George Heubel

Nat Hicks

Dick Higham

Jim Holdsworth

I

J

K

L

Terry Larkin

M

John Maloney

Phonney Martin

Bobby Mathews

Pat McGee

John McGuinness

John McMullin

Al Metcalf

Charlie Mills

N

Candy Nelson

Al Nichols

O

P

Tom Patterson

Dickey Pearce

Nealy Phelps

Q

R

Jack Remsen

S

George Seward

Jim Shanley

Orator Shaffer

Charlie Smith

Joe Start

T

Fred Treacey

Pete Treacey

U

V

Bob Valentine

W

Billy West

Rynie Wolters

X

Y

Z

References

External links

Franchise index at Baseball-Reference and Retrosheet

Major League Baseball all-time rosters

New York Mutuals

New York Mutuals all-time roster