This is an action by defendant in error against Badger, plaintiff in error, who was collector of the port of New Orleans, for the wrongful seizure and detention of the license, enrollment, shipping articles, and other papers of the schooner Theresa G, of which he was owner. The plaintiff, on the trial, recovered a verdict for the sum of $3,000 damages, and on his remitting $1,000 of the verdict a judgment was rendered for the remainder, with costs. A bill of exceptions set forth the facts in the case as follows:

'Be it remembered, that on the trial of this cause before a jury there was evidence introduced tending to show that the schooner Theresa G, whereof Frank Gutierez was master, sailed from Havana on ninth September, 1879, bound for the port of Shieldsborough; that on or about the twenty-ninth September, 1879, said vessel arrived in Grand Caillon bayou, an inlet of the Gulf of Mexico, lying within the customs collection district of the Teche; that the arrival of said vessel was not reported to collector of the district of the Teche, but that on the twenty-eighth October, 1879, while said vessel was lying in said bayou, and in said district of the Teche, Gutierez reported the arrival of the vessel to collector's office at Shieldsborough, which was the port of her registration, and, in the absence of the collector of that port, a deputy collector received from Gutierez the foreign register of said vessel, and issued to him a coasting license and enrollment.

Badger v. Gutierez/Opinion of the Court

'That on the thirty-first October the collector at Shieldsborough wrote to General Badger, collector port New Orleans, stating that said papers had been issued improperly in his absence, and requesting him, Badger, to get them from Gutierez; that on the first November, 1878, J. M. Tomlinson, chief clerk of Badger, collector, acting under instructions from Badger, found Gutierez for the purpose of inspection, obtained the papers issued at Shieldsborough from Gutierez; that from this date Badger, acting under the advice or instruction of the secretary of the treasury, refused to deliver the ship's papers to Gutierez, though demand d from him on the same day or subsequently.

Badger v. Gutierez/Opinion of the Court

'That on the fourth November, 1879, on information given by Badger, collector, the Theresa G was libeled for violation of section 2774, Rev. St., on part of master, and seized by marshal on sixteenth November; that on the eighteenth November, 1879, Gutierez filed his claim and bonded the vessel, and she was delivered up to him.

Badger v. Gutierez/Opinion of the Court

'That on the eighteenth November, 1879, Gutierez demanded from Badger the papers taken by Tomlinson, which Badger refused to deliver; that thereupon Badger reported the facts to the Secretary of the Treasury, who directed Badger to retain the papers issued at Shieldsborough, and subsequently directed Badger to send papers to Washington, D. C., which was done.

'That on eighteenth November, 1879, Badger stated to Gutierez that the Theresa G might be brought from Caillon bayou to New Orleans by S. W. Pass, Mississippi river, and he, Badger, thereupon sent to boarding officers written instructions to let vessel pass to New Orleans, but that Gutierez declined to bring his vessel on such permission; that this permission was declined by Gutierez on the ground that he must have in his possession documentary permission before he could safely navigate his vessel; that on January 9, 1880, written permission was given by Badger, collector, to master of the Theresa G to bring said vessel from Caillon bayou to Lookout station, in the collection district of New Orleans; that said vessel was thereupon brought to Lookout station, and that on the twenty-fourth day of January, 1880, Collector Badger granted clearance papers to said vessel.