The Model Code of Conduct serves as a regulatory structure aimed at maintaining fairness and ethical standards and freedom in campaigning. These guidelines are aimed at enhancing the integrity of the electoral process by strengthening values such as transparency, fairness, and accountability. However, the data & details of complaints on such violations are not readily available in the public domain with criticism of subjective interpretation of the guidelines by the ECI. In the ongoing 2024 General Elections, the Election Commission of India (ECI) barred K. Chandrasekhar Rao, President, Bharat Rashtra Samithi (BRS) and former Chief Minister of Telangana, from holding any election-related public activity for 48 hours between 01 May and 03 May. This unprecedented action invited wrath from various political segments questioning the inaction of the ECI on other similar alleged violations by other Parties and the Prime Minister of India himself. In today’s story, we look at the brief history of the Model Code of Conduct, its evolution over time, some statistics on violations, and criticisms of its application. What and why of Model Code of Conduct (MCC)? The Model Code of Conduct serves as a regulatory structure aimed at maintaining fairness and ethical standards and freedom in campaigning. These guidelines are aimed at enhancing the integrity of the electoral process by strengthening values such as transparency, fairness, and accountability. Despite lacking legal enforcement, the MCC has gradually established itself as a morally binding set of ethical guidelines and serves as a benchmark for political parties’ behaviour. It comes into force from the time of the announcement of elections. Evolution of MCC The Model Code of Conduct was initially introduced during the 1960 Kerala State Assembly elections. By the 1962 Lok Sabha general elections, it was officially disseminated to all political parties with an appeal for their agreement. Over time, as electoral circumstances shifted, adjustments were made to the Model Code of Conduct. The MCC consists of Eight parts, each dealing with different aspects of election campaigning. Section I covers general conduct, while Sections II and III address meetings and procession. Sections IV and V deal with polling day and Polling booth respectively. Section VI deals with observers and Section VII is particularly vital as it focuses on the conduct of the party in power, which wields significant influence. Likewise, Section VIII, the most recent addition, pertains to guidelines on election manifestos. The ambit of MCC evolved concerning the changing electoral scenarios. In 2004, the ECI, upon the directions of the Apex court, issued directions for setting up of committee that examines and certifies advertisements of a political nature on TV Channels and cable networks. The Election Commission of India also instructed all the electoral officials in 2009 to maintain a party-wise register to track the instances of violations being committed by various candidates and campaigners of various political parties, and this violation index should be put out in the public domain. However, there is no such publicly available database of MCC violations. Further, during the 2019 elections, the Election Commission of India, under the powers of Article 324 of the Indian Constitution, barred the display/exhibit of any biopic/publicity material during the MCC period. How are MCC violations collated? The Election Commission of India (ECI) has dedicated MCC Teams tasked with ensuring compliance with ECI directives regarding the Model Code of Conduct by officials, candidates, political parties, media outlets, etc., across all levels. If any violations were reported post-election announcement, these teams conduct thorough inquiries and forward the findings for appropriate action. Daily reports on MCC violations are compiled and managed by the MCC Team. MCC complaints are usually received from the General Public, Political Parties, Media, and Others including Independent Candidates, BLOs, Government officers, etc. Additionally, Flying Squads (FS), Static Surveillance Teams (SST), Video Viewing Teams (VVT), Video Surveillance Teams (VST), and Check Posts are deployed to monitor excessive campaign expenditures, distribution of bribes in cash or kind, illegal movement of arms, ammunition, liquor, or antisocial elements within the geographical segments during the electoral process. Despite all these, there is no central database for publication of all such cases of MCC violations in the public domain. The ECI launched the cVIGIL app during the Parliament elections 2019, which enables citizens to report MCC Violations and act as a unified database of publications of all such cases of MCC violations.
Justice Brief
Explainer: The What, Why, and How of the Model Code of Conduct (MCC) for Elections
Tags