Professor James Challis, of the University of Cambridge, England, in the prosecution of a "Mathematical Theory of Heat," published in the Philosophical Magazine for March, 1859, advanced in November of the same year, to a " Mathematical Theory of Attractive Forces," based on the assumption " that all substances consist of minute spherical atoms of different but constant magnitudes, and of the same intrinsic inertia; and that the dynamical relations and movements of different substances, and of their constituent atoms, are determined by the pressures of the aether against the surfaces of the atoms, together with the reaction of the atoms against such pressure by reason of the constancy of their form and magnitudes. The aether is assumed to be a uniform elastic fluid medium pervading all space not occupied by atoms, and varying in pressure proportionally to variations of its density. The theory recognizes no other kinds of force than these two, the one an active force resident in the aether, and the other a passive reaction of the atoms."

After a formidable array of partial differential equations, the author concludes: "Having now shown that waves of large breadth attract a small spherical body toward their origin, and having previously shown that waves of small breadth may repel such a body in the contrary direction, the main difficulty in forming a theory of attractive and repulsive forces seems to be overcome." It is supposed by Professor Challis that by the disturbance of a material element, a series of undulations differing greatly in their order of magnitude and velocity maybe simultaneously propagated in the aetherial medium, giving rise to as many different manifestations of force ; and that according to their relative wavelength, some of these will produce a permanent motion of translation on molecules of determinate mass subjected to their influence. This is partly in accord with the striking experiments of Guyot previously referred to.

Kinetic Theories of Gravitation/Challis, 1859

In a following paper the author undertook A Theory of the Force of Gravity;" remarking that, "As we have no conception from personal experience and sensation of any other species of force than pressure, the actio in distans does not admit of being explained by any previous or [248] concomitant knowledge, but if it be a reality, must forever remain to us incomprehensible." How the school-boy's personal experience of the strain exerted in drawing by a cord his winter's sled can be resolved into a sensation of "pressure" does not seem easy of discovery.

Kinetic Theories of Gravitation/Challis, 1859

Assuming then an order of aetherial waves having a much larger range than those of light. Professor Challis endeavors to deduce the several laws, of action proportional to the number of atoms acted upon, of the inverse square of the distance of action, and of simultaneous action in different directions. He infers that if such waves encountered a slight retardation of propagation in passing through the earth, they would be refracted, so to speak, by the form of the large inequalities of the terrestrial surface, producing the observed deflection of the plumbline.

Kinetic Theories of Gravitation/Challis, 1859

He also supposes that a small function involving r must be added to the usual formula m/r² increasing sensibly the action of the sun near its surface and diminishing its action notably through interstellar distances. He thinks that this alone will explain why the sidereal system does not collapse toward its common center of gravity. "According to the theory of gravity I have proposed, although the ordinary law may be exact through the solar system and far beyond, there must be distances at which the condition that the excursions of the vibrating particles of the aether are large compared to the dimensions of the atoms ceases to be fulfilled. In that case the attraction changes to repulsion."