"And I'm more than glad to see you back here," the colonel exploded. "I've been worrying about you. Did you have any luck?"
"Unless I am greatly mistaken we have the cup right with us, in this box," said Don quietly. He placed it on the desk.

"We'll open it and see," the colonel stated.

A hammer was procured from a nearby closet and with a few swift blows the colonel broke open the wooden box. As the last board fell away a somewhat tarnished silver cup was disclosed to view. The colonel raised it from the box and they looked at the inscription on the side. It read: "Presented to Woodcrest Military Institute by Melvin R. Gates for Excellence in Scholastic Effort. Won by Arthur F. Gates of the Senior Class, April 7, 1933."

Without a word the colonel turned it up so they could all see what was written on the bottom. All of them craned forward to read the brief message which had been written deep into the silver by the aid of a pin or knife.
The message was simple but tragic. It read: "I cheated. Arthur Gates."
There was a moment of silence on the part of the colonel and his loyal cadets. Then the colonel said very quietly, "You see what it means, boys?"
"I think I do," nodded Don in a low voice. "After Gates had promised Long that he would confess his dishonorable action he said he would write it where it would stand for good. Long didn't know what he meant by that, but when he had left the room Gates scratched that confession on the bottom of the cup with a sharp instrument."
"Yes," went on the colonel. "Long never knew of that, and during the night Gates must have experienced a change of heart, so he took the cup on the following morning. He knew that Long would expose him if he went back on his promise to confess, so he stole that cup in order to create an atmosphere that would make Long the butt of ridicule if he ever came out with the story of Gates' dishonesty."
"How can a man with any sense of common decency do a thing like that?" wondered Jim.
The colonel shrugged his shoulders. "I'm very much afraid that Arthur Gates was never a shining light of virtue. We have found out that he was dismissed from at least one school for an offense such as he committed here. You can see that he would never have the courage to face the school and say, 'Gentlemen, I cheated.' Under Long's persuasion he relented long enough to write the confession on the cup, but I guess he bitterly regretted his act later."





