[Sidenote: Comparative barrenness of the whole.]

In this first division of English prosodists there is observable a want of thoroughness--at first sight perhaps strange, but easily explicable--which makes most of their work little more than a curiosity. The only book which attempts to grapple somewhat methodically with the whole subject--that attributed to Puttenham--labours under two fatal disadvantages. The first is that the writer has a most imperfect knowledge, or rather an almost unmixed ignorance, of what has come before him; and the second is that he naturally cannot know what will come after him, while what actually did come immediately after him happens to be one of the greatest bodies, in bulk and merit and variety, of English poetry. The two most gifted persons who think of treating it, Jonson and Dryden, do not actually do so; and it may be more than doubted whether, had they done so, ignorance of the past would not still have stood in their way. It is true that Dryden's _obiter dictum_, that you must not elide what you must pronounce, is a sort of ark of salvation which carries all the elements of a sound prosody in it. But it is not certain that the writer quite saw its full bearing, and that bearing was certainly not seen by others. On the other hand, Gascoigne's innocent but unlucky remark about the single two-syllabled foot expresses an opinion which, though wholly erroneous, undoubtedly did prevail very widely throughout the whole period. The evidence of its falsity was indeed constantly accumulating in blank verse during the first half of the seventeenth century, in definite trisyllabic metres during the second. But this evidence was ignored or disobligingly received; and when, at the very beginning of the eighteenth, Bysshe once more attempted formulation of prosodic orthodoxy, he arranged a code which, as long as it was observed, half maimed the sinews and half throttled the song of English poetry.

Historical Manual of English Prosody — Part 162

[130] Perhaps general for a stanza. Certainly used in one case for a six-lined one of four longer lines and two shorter.

Historical Manual of English Prosody — Part 162

[131] In his _Troy Book_ he says that, "as tho" [at that time] he "set aside truth of metre," "had no guide in that art," and "took no heed of short and long."

Historical Manual of English Prosody — Part 162