In your former letters you say that I made use of these words to you: "You will be retrograde that you may spring the farther forward." You have misquoted, Southey! You had talked of rejoining pantisocracy in about fourteen years. I exploded this probability, but as I saw you determined to leave it, hoped and wished it might be so--_hoped_ that we might run backwards only to leap forward. Not to mention that during that conversation I had taken the weight and pressing urgency of your motives as truths granted; but when, on examination, I found them a show and mockery of unreal things, doubtless, my opinion of you _must_ have become far less respectful. You quoted likewise the last sentence of my letter to you, as a proof that I approved of your design; you _knew_ that sentence to imply no more than the pious confidence of optimism--however wickedly you might act, God would make it _ultimately_ the best. You _knew_ this was the meaning of it--I could find twenty parallel passages in the lectures. Indeed, such expressions applied to bad actions had become a habit of my conversation. You had named, not unwittingly, Dr. Pangloss. And Heaven forbid that I should not now have faith that however foul your stream may run here, yet that it will filtrate and become pure in its subterraneous passage to the Ocean of Universal Redemption.
Thus far had I written when the necessities of literary occupation crowded upon me, and I met you in Redcliff, and, unsaluted and unsaluting, passed by the man to whom for almost a year I had told my last thoughts when I closed my eyes, and the first when I awoke. But "ere this I have felt sorrow!"
I shall proceed to answer your letters, and first excriminate myself, and then examine your conduct. You charge me with having industriously trumpeted your uncle's letter. When I mentioned my intended journey to Clevedon with Burnett, and was asked by my immediate friends why _you_ were not with us, should I have been silent and implied something mysterious, or have told an open untruth and made myself your accomplice? I could do neither; I answered that you were quite undetermined, but had some thoughts of returning to Oxford. To Danvers, indeed, and to Cottle I spoke more particularly, for I knew their prudence and their love for you--and my heart was very full. But to Mrs. Morgan I did not mention it. She met me in the streets, and said: "So! Southey is going into the Church! 'Tis all concluded, 'tis in vain to deny it!" I answered: "You are mistaken; you must contradict; Southey has received a splendid offer, but he has not determined." This, I have some faint recollection, was my answer, but of this particular conversation my recollection is very faint. By what means she received the intelligence I know not; probably from Mrs. Richardson, who might have been told it by Mr. Wade. A considerable time after, the subject was renewed at Mrs. Morgan's, Burnett and my Sara being present. Mrs. M. told me that you had asserted to her, that with regard to the Church you had barely hesitated, that you might consider your uncle's arguments, that you had given up no one principle--and that _I_ was more your friend than ever. I own I was roused to an agony of passion; nor was George Burnett undisturbed. Whatever I said that afternoon (and since that time I have but often repeated what I said, in gentler language) George Burnett did give his _decided Amen_ to. And I said, Southey, that you had given up every principle--that confessedly you were going into the law, more opposite to your avowed principles, if possible, than even the Church--and that I had in my pocket a letter in which you charged me with having withdrawn my friendship; and as to your barely hesitating about your uncle's proposal, I was obliged in my own defence to relate all that passed between us, all on which I had founded a conviction so directly opposite.