[5] In connexion with this it may be mentioned that, in the females of Brachyscelus, in which the posterior antennæ are deficient, the conical processes with the canal permeating them are nevertheless retained.

[6] Compare the figure given by Darwin (Balanidæ Pl. xxx fig. 5) of the first natatory foot of the pupa of _Lepas australis,_ with that of _Lernæodiscus Porcellanæ_ published in the ‘Archiv für Naturgeschichte’ (1863, Taf. iii, fig. 5). The sole distinction, that in the latter there are only 3 setæ at the end of the outer branch, whilst in the Cirripedia there are 4 on the first and 5 on the following natatory feet, may be due to an error on my part.

Facts and Arguments for Darwin — Part 47

[7] Darwin describes as “acoustic orifices” small apertures in the shell of the pupæ of the Cirripedia, which, frequently surrounded by a border, are situated, in _Lepas pectinata,_ upon short, horn-like processes. I feel scarcely any hesitation in regarding the apertures as those of the “shell-glands,” and the horn-like processes as remains of the frontal horns.

Facts and Arguments for Darwin — Part 47

[8] The roots of _Sacculina purpurea_ (Fig. 60) which is parasitic upon a small Hermit Crab, are made use of by two parasitic Isopods, namely a Bopyrus and the before mentioned _Cryptoniscus planarioides_ (Fig. 42). These take up their abode beneath the _Sacculina_ and cause it to die away by intercepting the nourishment conveyed by the roots; the roots, however, continue to grow, even without the _Sacculina,_ and frequently attain an extraordinary extension, especially when a _Bopyrus_ obtains its nourishment from them.

Facts and Arguments for Darwin — Part 47

[9] I have not mentioned the Pycnogonidæ, because I do not regard them as Crustacea; nor the Xiphosura and Trilobites, because, having never investigated them myself, I knew too little about them, and especially because I am unacquainted with the details of the explanations given by Barrande of the development of the latter. According to Mr. Spence Bate “the young of Trilobites are of the Nauplius-form.”)

CHAPTER X. ON THE PRINCIPLES OF CLASSIFICATION.

Perhaps some one else, more fortunate than myself, may be able, even without Darwin, to find the guiding clue through the confusion of developmental forms, now so totally different in the nearest allies, now so surprisingly similar in members of the most distant groups, which we have just cursorily reviewed. Perhaps a sharper eye may be able, with Agassiz, to make out “the plan established from the beginning by the Creator,”[1] who may have written here, as a Portuguese proverb says “straight in crooked lines.”[2] I cannot but think that we can scarcely speak of a general plan, or typical mode of development of the Crustacea, differentiated according to the separate Sections, Orders, and Families, when, for example, among the Macrura, the River Crayfish leaves the egg in its permanent form; the Lobster with Schizopodal feet; _Palæmon,_ like the Crabs, as a Zoëa; and _Penéus,_ like the Cirripedes, as a Nauplius,—and when, still, within this same sub-order Macrura, _Palinurus, Mysis_ and _Euphausia_ again present different young forms,—when new limbs sometimes sprout forth as free rudiments on the ventral surface, and are sometimes formed beneath the skin which passes smoothly over them, and both modes of development are found in different limbs of the same animal and in the same pair of limbs in different animals,—when in the Podophthalma the limbs of the thorax and abdomen make their appearance sometimes simultaneously, or sometimes the former and sometimes the latter first, and when further in each of the two groups the pairs sometimes all appear together, and sometimes one after the other,—when, among the Hyperina, a simple foot becomes a chela in _Phronima_ and a chela a simple foot in _Brachyscelus,_ etc.