You are certainly well calculated for the review you meditate. Your answer to Burke is, I will not say, the best, for that would be no praise; it is certainly the only good one, and it is a very good one. In style and in _reflectiveness_ it is, I think, your _chef d'oeuvre_. Yet the "Peripatetic"[117]--for which accept my thanks--pleased me more because it let me into your heart; the poetry is frequently _sweet_ and possesses the _fire_ of feeling, but not enough (I think) of the _light_ of fancy. I am sorry that you should entertain so degrading an opinion of me as to imagine that I _industriously_ collected anecdotes unfavourable to the characters of great men. No, Thelwall, but I cannot shut my ears, and I have never given a moment's belief to any one of those stories unless when they were related to me at different times by professed democrats. My vice is of the opposite class, a precipitance in praise; witness my panegyric on Gerrald and that _black_ gentleman Margarot in the "Conciones," and my foolish verses to Godwin in the "Morning Chronicle."[118] At the same time, Thelwall, do not suppose that I admit your palliations. Doubtless I could fill a book with slanderous stories of _professed Christians_, but those very men would allow they were acting contrary to Christianity; but, I am afraid, an atheistic bad man manufactures his system of principles with an eye to his peculiar propensities, and makes his actions the criterion of what is virtuous, not virtue the criterion of his actions. Where the _disposition_ is not amiable, an acute understanding I deem no blessing. To the last sentence in your letter I subscribe fully and with all my inmost affections. "He who thinks and _feels_ will be virtuous; and he who is absorbed in self will be vicious, whatever maybe his speculative opinions." Believe me, Thelwall, it is not his atheism that has prejudiced me against Godwin, but Godwin who has, perhaps, _prejudiced_ me against atheism. Let me see you--I already know a deist, and Calvinists, and Moravians whom I love and reverence--and I shall leap forwards to realise my _principles_ by _feeling_ love and honour for an atheist. By the bye, are you an atheist? For I was told that Hutton was an atheist, and procured his three massy quartos on the principle of knowledge in the hopes of finding some arguments in favor of atheism, but lo! I discovered him to be a profoundly pious deist,--"independent of fortune, satisfied with himself, pleased with his species, confident in his Creator."
Neighborhoods Digest
Letters of Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Vol. I (of 2) — Part 102
Tags