OTHER MARCAN PASSAGES CONSIDERED, BUT REJECTED
In addition to the passages assigned to Q in the preceding investigation, several are suggested by Streeter and Wernle. Streeter suggests Mk xiii, 15-16; but the doublets in Luke are apparently taken in both instances from Mark. Streeter thinks that xiii, 28-32, "has a genuine sound"; but there is nothing more specific to prove its presence in Q. Streeter's suggestion that Mk i, 2-3, is from Q seems unjustifiable. Vs. 3 is an Old Testament quotation which Matthew, Mark, and Luke all have in common. If it stood originally in Mark and is not to be regarded as a later addition, there is no occasion for the assumption of Q. Vs. 2 could hardly have stood in its present place when Matthew and Luke used Mark. It occurs in another connection in Matthew and Luke (Mt xi, 10; Lk vii, 27), and was probably copied from there into its present place by a later hand.
Wernle's additions to the above Q material in Mark do not seem to be justified. Some of them, e.g., Mk xi, 14, rest upon making doublets (in this case Mt xxi, 19, and vii, 7-8) where the wording is not close enough to warrant them. Others rest upon the general character of the sayings. The latter is a tempting criterion, and in Matthew and Luke, who demonstrably make such extensive use of Q, it is more justifiable and has been used to some extent in the preceding analyses. But in Mark, where Q is so sparingly and loosely used, it cannot be safely employed aside from other indications, especially the occurrence of doublets.
The writer believes that the matter listed in the above tabulation is about all that can at present safely be assigned to Q in Mark. It yields us, as new Q material in Matthew, sixteen verses, and as new Q material in Luke, seventeen. This would bring the totals for Q material in Matthew and Luke up to two hundred and eighty-three in Matthew and to two hundred and fifty-five in Luke.[134] The number of verses in Mark which can be traced to Q are about fifty. All but sixteen of these verses in Matthew and all but seventeen in Luke had already been assigned to Q. Only one stands in Mark alone.
----------------------------------------------------------------------- Sec.|Chap.| Verse | Subject |Source ----|-----|-------|---------------------------------------------|------ 1 | i,| 7-8 |Messianic announcement of the Baptist | Q 2 | i,| 12-13 |The temptation | Q 3 | iii,| 22-29 |The Beelzebul controversy | Q 4 | iv,| 21 |The light and the bushel | Q 5 | iv,| 22 |Things hidden and revealed | Q 6 | iv,| 24 |With what measure (about judging) | Q 7 | iv,| 25 |Whoever has, to him shall be given | Q 8 | iv,| 30-32 |Parable of the Mustard Seed | Q 9 | vi,| 7-11 |Mission of the twelve, what to take, conduct | | | |by the way, if any place does not receive you| Q 10 |viii,| 12 |A sign refused | Q 11 |viii,| 34,38 |Conditions of discipleship | Q 12 | ix,| 42 |About offenses | Q 13 | ix,| 49-50 |Salt is good. If the salt has lost, etc. | Q 14 | x,| 11-12 |About divorce | Q 15 | x,| 31 |First last and last first | Q 16 | x,| 43-44 |Whoso would be great among you | Q 17 | xi,| 23 |About faith | Q 18 | xii,| 38-40 |Against Pharisaism | Q 19 |xiii,| 11 |Take no thot what ye shall say | Q -----------------------------------------------------------------------