There were some verses of yours in the last "Monthly Magazine" with which I was much pleased--calm good sense combined with _feeling_, and conveyed in harmonious verse and a chaste and pleasing imagery. I wish much, very much, to see your other poem. As to your Poems which you informed me in the accompanying letter that you had sent in the same parcel with the pamphlets, whether or no your verses had more than their _proper number of feet_ I cannot say; but certain it is, that somehow or other they _marched off_. No "Poems by John Thelwall" could I find. When I charged you with anti-religious bigotry, I did not allude to your pamphlet, but to passages in your letters to me, and to a circumstance which Southey, I _think_, once mentioned, that you had asserted that the name of _God_ ought never to be produced in poetry.[136] Which, to be sure, was carrying hatred _to your Creator very far indeed_.

My dear Thelwall! "It is the principal felicity of life and the chief glory of manhood to speak out fully on all subjects." I will avail myself of it. I will express _all_ my feelings, but will previously take care to make my feelings benevolent. Contempt is hatred without fear; anger, hatred accompanied with apprehension. But because hatred is always evil, contempt must be always evil, and a good man ought to speak _contemptuously_ of nothing. I am sure a wise man will not of opinions which have been held by men, in _other_ respects at least, confessed of more powerful intellect than himself. 'Tis an assumption of _infallibility_; for if a man were wakefully mindful that what he now thinks foolish he may himself hereafter think wise, it is not in nature that he should _despise_ those who now believe what it is possible he may himself hereafter believe; and if he deny the possibility he must _on that point_ deem himself infallible and immutable. Now, in your letter of yesterday, you speak with _contempt_ of two things: old age and the Christian religion; though religion was believed by Newton, Locke, and Hartley, after intense investigation, which in each had been preceded by unbelief. This does not prove its truth, but it should save its followers from _contempt_, even though through the infirmities of mortality they should have _lost their teeth_. I call that man a bigot, Thelwall, whose intemperate zeal, for or against any opinions, leads him to contradict himself in the space of half a dozen lines. Now this you appear to me to have done. I will write fully to you now, because I shall never renew the subject. I shall not be idle in defence of the religion I profess, and my books will be the place, not my letters. You say the Christian is a _mean_ religion. Now the religion which Christ taught is simply, first, that there is an omnipresent Father of infinite power, wisdom, and goodness, in whom we all of us move and have our being; and, secondly, that when we appear to men to die we do not utterly perish, but after this life shall continue to enjoy or suffer the consequences and natural effects of the habits we have formed here, whether good or evil. This is the Christian _religion_, and all of the Christian _religion_. That there is no _fancy_ in it I readily grant, but that it is mean and deficient in _mind_ and _energy_ it were impossible for me to admit, unless I admitted that there _could be_ no dignity, intellect, or force in anything but _atheism_. But though it appeal not itself to the fancy, the truths which it teaches admit the highest exercise of it. Are the "innumerable multitude of angels and archangels" less splendid beings than the countless gods and goddesses of Rome and Greece? And can you seriously think that Mercury from Jove equals in poetic sublimity "the mighty angel that came down from heaven, whose face was as it were the sun and his feet as pillars of fire: who set his right foot on the sea, and his left foot on the earth. And he sent forth a loud voice; and when he had sent it forth, seven thunders uttered their voices: and when the seven thunders had uttered their voices, the mighty Angel[137] lifted up his hand to heaven, and sware by Him that liveth for ever and ever that _Time_ was no more"? Is not Milton a sublimer poet than Homer or Virgil? Are not his personages more sublimely clothed, and do you not know that there is not perhaps _one page_ in _Milton's_ Paradise Lost in which he has not borrowed his imagery from the _Scriptures_? I allow and rejoice that _Christ_ appealed only to the understanding and the affections; but I affirm that after reading Isaiah, or St. Paul's "Epistle to the Hebrews," Homer and Virgil are disgustingly _tame_ to me, and Milton himself barely tolerable.

Letters of Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Vol. I (of 2) — Part 119