In this week’s review of Court Judgments, we look at Supreme Court’s observation that Insurance claims can’t be rejected based on ambiguous term, Allahabad High Court invoking Doctrine of Parens Patrie, Madras High Court’s observation that Employee’s suspension cannot extend endlessly merely due to pendency of criminal cases, Calcutta High Court quashing the case of husband and stating wife can’t be stopped from residing with visually challenged mother and Karnataka High court reiterating that merely being a attesting witness doesn’t make one an accused. Supreme Court: Insurance claims can’t be rejected based on ambiguous term While hearing the appeal related to the case, M/S Mehta Jewellers vs. National Insurance Company Ltd. a division bench of the Supreme Court, comprising Justice Hima Kohli and Justice P.S.Narasimha, observed that the claim arising out of an insurance policy cannot be repudiated on the basis of a term in the policy which is itself ambiguous. The case is related to an insurance policy purchased by one Mehta Jewellers from National Insurance Company Ltd. for insuring ornaments in its showroom in Pune. A burglary took place in 2007, and several of the gold ornaments were stolen. However, the claim for insurance was repudiated stating that the ornaments in the shop at the time of the burglary were kept in a steel safe of local make and not in a burglar-resistant safe. The appeal in the Supreme Court was filed by the appellant challenging the order of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission wherein it dismissed the claim on the ground that a simple steel almirah cannot be described as a safe and the lock installed is not complex. Prior to that, the appellant challenged the denial of its claim before the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission. The Commission ruled in the appellant’s favour and directed the respondent to pay an amount of ₹ 28,95,600/- along with interest. This order was taken in an appeal by the respondent before the National Commission. The National Commission, in its order, had allowed the appeal. It observed that the almirah could be opened by widening the space between the doors of the almirah. It also noted that in common parlance, a normal steel almirah is not referred to as Safe, which is generally understood to be a strong metal cabinet with a special lock where valuables like money, jewellery, important documents, etc. are kept. This was challenged in the Supreme Court. The Court allowed the appeal observing that it was unjustified on the part of the respondent to repudiate the claim of the appellant for the sum claimed. It observed that the insurance policy itself does not define the word ‘locked safe’ nor does it define what should be the standard make of the ‘locked safe’. In its judgment, the Supreme Court upheld the amount awarded by the State Commission in favour of the appellant. Allahabad HC: Invokes Doctrine of Parens Patrie and appoints wife as guardian of husband in comatose. As per the details of the case, Pooja Sharma vs. State of U.P and others, the petitioner, who is the wife of a person in a comatose state, approached the High Court to be appointed as her husband’s guardian, to enable her to dispose of the property registered in his name. The wife wanted to sell the property to meet the expenses for her husband’s treatment, who is in a permanent vegetative state due to a head injury. The court has earlier directed the Director, AIIMS to constitute a medical board consisting of specialist doctors dealing with such conditions. As per the report submitted before the court, it was stated that the husband requires prolonged supportive and nursing care and is unlikely to make a significant neurological recovery in the near future. In view of the condition of the husband who is in a coma and a permanent vegetative state, the question for consideration for the court was to determine who would be the guardian of such a person to handle the property, as there is no provision in the Mental Health Act and Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 for a person in a vegetative state. The Court observed that although there is a clear distinction between the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, and the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, however, neither provides for the guardian of a person in a comatose state. The Court relied on Aruna Ramchandra Shanbaug vs. Union Of India & Ors, wherein the Supreme Court held that a person in minimally conscious state, though not fully coherent, is able to interact shall be governed by the Rights of People with Disabilities Act, 2016. However, a person in a permanent vegetative state will not be covered within the definition of persons with disabilities and hence excluded from the ambit of the Act.