————————————

Chapter I.—The Life and Writings

of St. Hilary of Poitiers.

of Poitiers is

one of the greatest, yet least studied, of the Fathers of the Western

Church. He has suffered thus, partly from a certain obscurity in

his style of writing, partly from the difficulty of the thoughts which

he attempted to convey. But there are other reasons for the

comparative neglect into which he has fallen. He learnt his

theology, as we shall see, from Eastern authorities, and was not

content to carry on and develop the traditional teaching of the West; and the disciple of Origen, who found his natural allies in the Cappadocian school of Basil and the Gregories, his juniors though they were, was speaking to somewhat unsympathetic ears. Again, his Latin tongue debarred him from influence in the East, and he suffered, like all Westerns, from that deep suspicion of Sabellianism which was rooted in the Eastern Churches. Nor are these the only reasons for the neglect of Hilary. Of his two chief works, the Homilies on the Psalms, important as they were in popularising the allegorical method of interpretation, were soon outdone in favour by other commentaries; while his great controversial work on the Trinity suffered from its very perfection for the purpose with which it was composed. It seems, at first sight, to be not a refutation of Arianism, or of any particular phase of Arianism, but of one particular document, the Epistle of Arius to Alexander, in which Arian doctrines are expressed; and that a document which, in the constantly shifting phases of the controversy, soon fell into an oblivion which the work of Hilary has nearly shared. It is only incidentally constructive; its plan follows, in the central portion, that of the production of Arius which he was controverting, and this negative method must have lessened its popularity for purposes of practical instruction, and in competition with such a masterpiece as the De Trinitate of St. Augustine. And furthermore, Hilary never does himself justice. He was a great original thinker in the field of Christology, but he has never stated his views systematically and completely. They have to be laboriously reconstructed by the collection of passages scattered throughout his works; and though he is a thinker so consistent that little or no conjecture is needed for the piecing together of his system, yet we cannot be surprised full justice has never been done to him. He has been regarded chiefly as one of the sufferers from the violence of Constantius, as the composer of a useful conspectus of arguments against Arianism, as an unsuccessful negotiator for an understanding between the Eastern and Western Churches; but his sufferings were as nothing compared to those of Athanasius, while his influence in controversy seems to have been as small as the results of his diplomacy. It is not his practical share, in word or deed, in the conflicts of his day that is his chief title to fame, but his independence and depth as a Christian thinker. He has, indeed, exerted an important influence upon the growth of doctrine, but it has been through the adoption of his views by Augustine and Ambrose; and many who have profited by his thoughts have never known who was their author.

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume IX/Title Page/Introduction/The Life and Writings of St. Hilary of Poitiers

Hilary of Poitiers, the most impersonal of writers, is

so silent about himself, he is so rarely mentioned by contemporary

writers—in all the voluminous works of Athanasius he is never

once named,—and the ancient historians of the Church knew so

little concerning him beyond what we, as well as they, can learn from

his writings, that nothing more than a very scanty narrative can be

constructed from these, as seen in the light of the general history of

the time and combined with the few notices of him found

elsewhere. But the account, though short, cannot be seriously

defective. Apart from one or two episodes, it is eminently the

history of a mind, and of a singularly consistent mind, whose

antecedents we can, in the main, recognise, and whose changes of

thought are few, and can be followed.

Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers: Series II/Volume IX/Title Page/Introduction/The Life and Writings of St. Hilary of Poitiers