No new Thoughts or Sentiments are to be found in this Performance, we meet only with old ones absurdly expressed. _Dryden_ said that _Ben Johnson_ was every where to be traced in the Snow of the Ancients. We may say that _Malloch_ is every where to be traced in the Puddle of the Moderns. Instead of selecting the Beauties, he has pick'd out whatever is despicable in _Shakespeare_, _Otway_, _Dryden_, and _Rowe_, like a Pick-Pocket who dives for Handkerchiefs, not for Gold; and contents himself with what he finds in our Great Coat Pocket, without attempting our Watch or your Purse. Tho' Mr. _Malloch_ may only mean to borrow, yet as he possesses no Fund of Original Genius from whence he can pay his Debts, borrowing, we are afraid is an inadequate Expression, the harsher one of stealing we must therefore, tho' reluctantly, substitute in its room. In the Prologue he acknowledges himself a Culprit, but as the Loss of what he has pilfered is insignificant to the Owners, we shall bring him in guilty only of Petty Larcenary: We believe he has been driven, like poor People in this severe Weather by dire Necessity, to such dishonest Shifts.

In this Play the Author has introduced a Rebellion unparalleled in any History, Ancient or Modern. He raises his Rebellions as a skilful Gardener does his Mushrooms, in a Moment; and like an artful Nurse, he lulls in a Moment the fretful Child asleep. The Prince enters an Appartment of the Palace with a drawn Sword; this forms the Rebellion. The King enters the same Appartment without a drawn Sword. This quashes the Rebellion. How to credit this Story, or to pardon this poetical Licence, we are greatly at a Loss; for we know in the Year 1745 three thousand Mountaineers actually appeared at _Derby_. _Cataline_, we are credibly informed, had a Gang of at least a Dozen stout Fellows; and it is pretty certain that _Bedemar_, when going to inslave _Venice_, had provided Pistols and Battle Powder for more than fifteen fighting Men. We are almost tempted to think, that Mr. _Malloch_ gets his Rebellions ready made, like his _Scotch_ Tobacco, cut and dry, at the Sign of the Valiant Highlander.

Critical Strictures on the New Tragedy of Elvira, Written by Mr. David Malloch (1763) — Part 7

Our great Author possesses, in its utmost Perfection, the happy Art of uniting rival Ladies, and of setting at Variance a virtuous Father and Son. How intimate his Acquaintance with Human Nature! How deep his Knowledge of the Passions! No less exquisite and refined in his Morality, like a true Disciple of Lord _Bolingbroke_, he unites Vice and Virtue most lovingly together; witness this memorable Line of the King's, addressed to _Elvira_;

Critical Strictures on the New Tragedy of Elvira, Written by Mr. David Malloch (1763) — Part 7