Very much the same principles are at work with us to-day, whence _a_ dreadnought from the prime "Dreadnought," and the etymologer of the future, who tries by strictly scientific methods to unravel the meaning of such words as _mackintosh_, _brougham_, _Sam Browne_, _gladstone_, _boycott_, etc., will find it necessary to investigate the legends attendant on those names rather than practice a formal permutation of vowels and consonants.
By common consent the quintessence of the last fifty years' philological progress is being distilled into Sir James Murray's _New English Dictionary_, and in a conciser form the same data may be found in Prof. Skeat's _Concise Etymological Dictionary of the English Language_. Both these indispensable works are high watermarks of English scholarship, and whatever absurdities they contain are shortcomings not of their compilers but of the Teutonic school of philology which they exemplify. If these two standard dictionaries were able to answer even the elementary questions that are put to them it would be both idle and presumptuous to cavil, but one has only to refer to their pages to realise the ignorance which prevails as to the origin and the meaning of the most simple and everyday words.
It is unfortunately true that "in philology as in all branches of knowledge it is the specialist who most strongly opposes any attempt to widen the field of his knowledge".[52] Hence, as was only to be expected, one of the reviewers of my _Lost Language of Symbolism_ deemed it quite insufferable that I should throw to the winds the laborious work on the science of phonetics built up by generations of careful research.
But in point of fact I discarded none of the sound work of my predecessors; I only tried to supplement it and fished deeper. My soundings do not begin until I am well beyond the limits of modern etymology, and they are no more affected by the cross-currents of historic languages than the activities of a deep-water fisherman are interrupted or affected by the tide eddies on the shore. The defect of official philology is that it offers no explanation for radicals. It does not, for example, attempt to explain why the word _ap_ was the Sanscrit for water, why _pri_ was the Sanscrit for love, or why _pat_ was the Sanscrit for fly. It refers the word oak to the Anglo-Saxon _ac_, Dr. Murray merely describing it as "a consonantal stem, ulterior meaning obscure". Etymology to-day is in fact very much in the situation of an insolvent bank which, unable to satisfy its creditors with cash on demand, blandly endeavours to satisfy them with corresponding cheques of equally uncashable face value. Words can never properly be interpreted merely by parallel words: originally they must have expressed ideas, and it is these underlying ideas that I am in search of. My previous work was a pioneer, and in many respects bungling attempt to pick up the threads where at present philology is content to lose them. Using the same keys as hitherto, I shall attempt to explore further the darkness which is at present the only achieved goal of the much trumpeted Science of Language.