For the farther proof of this, we may take occasion to consider the apostle’s method of reasoning, in the scripture but now referred to, _By one man sin entered into the world_, that is, by the first man, _in whom all have sinned_, Rom. v. 12. so I would choose to render it rather than as it is in our translation, since this seems to be the most natural sense of the word[59]; and it proves Adam, in whom all sinned, to be their head and representative, and also agrees best with the apostle’s general design, or argument, insisted on, and farther illustrated in the following verses.

Again, the apostle speaks of those penal evils consequent on Adam’s sins, which could not have befallen us, had he not been our federal head and representative; Thus, in ver. 18. _By the offence of one, judgment came upon all men to condemnation_[60]. It may be observed, that the apostle, in this text, uses a word, which we translate _condemnation_[61]; which cannot, with any manner of consistency, be taken in any other than a forensick sense; and therefore he argues, from thence, that we are liable to condemnation, by the offence of Adam; which certainly proves the imputation of his offence to us, and consequently he is considered therein as our federal head.

A Body of Divinity, Vol. 2 of 4 — Part 115

2. This farther appears, in that all mankind are exposed to many miseries, and to death, which are of a penal nature; therefore they must be considered, as the consequence of sin. Now they cannot be the consequence of actual sin, in those, who are miserable and die, as soon as they are born, who have not _sinned after the similitude of Adam’s transgression_; therefore this must be the result of his sin, which it could not be, had he not been the federal head of all his posterity.[62]

A Body of Divinity, Vol. 2 of 4 — Part 115

_Object._ It is objected to this, that God might, out of his mere sovereignty, ordain that his creatures should be exposed to some degree of misery; and, if this misery be not considered, as the punishment of sin, in infants, then it does not prove the imputation of Adam’s sin to them; and even their death, considered only as a separation of soul and body, may not contain in it a proper idea of punishment, (which consists in the stroke of justice, demanding satisfaction for sin) if it be only reckoned an expedient, or a necessary means for their attaining eternal life. Therefore it doth not follow, that, because we are liable to death, before we have done good or evil, it must necessarily be a punishment due to that sin, which was committed by Adam.

A Body of Divinity, Vol. 2 of 4 — Part 115