Nothing in this country furnishes a better example of how a business may

be turned from its function of service than do the railroads. We have a

railroad problem, and much learned thought and discussion have been

devoted to the solution of that problem. Everyone is dissatisfied with

the railways. The public is dissatisfied because both the passenger and

freight rates are too high. The railroad employees are dissatisfied

because they say their wages are too low and their hours too long. The

owners of the railways are dissatisfied because it is claimed that no

adequate return is realized upon the money invested. All of the contacts

of a properly managed undertaking ought to be satisfactory. If the

public, the employees, and the owners do not find themselves better off

because of the undertaking, then there must be something very wrong

indeed with the manner in which the undertaking is carried through.

I am entirely without any disposition to pose as a railroad authority. There may be railroad authorities, but if the service as rendered by the American railroad to-day is the result of accumulated railway knowledge, then I cannot say that my respect for the usefulness of that knowledge is at all profound. I have not the slightest doubt in the world that the active managers of the railways, the men who really do the work, are entirely capable of conducting the railways of the country to the satisfaction of every one, and I have equally no doubt that these active managers have, by force of a chain of circumstances, all but ceased to manage. And right there is the source of most of the trouble. The men who know railroading have not been allowed to manage railroads.

My Life and Work/16

In a previous chapter on finance were set forth the dangers attendant

upon the indiscriminate borrowing of money. It is inevitable that any

one who can borrow freely to cover errors of management will borrow

rather than correct the errors. Our railway managers have been

practically forced to borrow, for since the very inception of the

railways they have not been free agents. The guiding hand of the railway

has been, not the railroad man, but the banker. When railroad credit was

high, more money was to be made out of floating bond issues and

speculating in the securities than out of service to the public. A very

small fraction of the money earned by the railways has gone back into

the rehabilitation of the properties. When by skilled management the net

revenue became large enough to pay a considerable dividend upon the

stock, then that dividend was used first by the speculators on the

inside and controlling the railroad fiscal policy to boom the stock and

unload their holdings, and then to float a bond issue on the strength of

the credit gained through the earnings. When the earnings dropped or

were artificially depressed, then the speculators bought back the stock

and in the course of time staged another advance and unloading. There is

scarcely a railroad in the United States that has not been through one

or more receiverships, due to the fact that the financial interests

piled on load after load of securities until the structures grew

topheavy and fell over. Then they got in on the receiverships, made

money at the expense of gullible security holders, and started the same

old pyramiding game all over again.

My Life and Work/16

The natural ally of the banker is the lawyer. Such games as have been

played on the railroads have needed expert legal advice. Lawyers, like

bankers, know absolutely nothing about business. They imagine that a

business is properly conducted if it keeps within the law or if the law

can be altered or interpreted to suit the purpose in hand. They live on

rules. The bankers took finance out of the hands of the managers. They

put in lawyers to see that the railroads violated the law only in legal

fashion, and thus grew up immense legal departments. Instead of

operating under the rules of common sense and according to

circumstances, every railroad had to operate on the advice of counsel. Rules spread through every part of the organization. Then came the avalanche of state and federal regulations, until to-day we find the railways hog-tied in a mass of rules and regulations. With the lawyers and the financiers on the inside and various state commissions on the outside, the railway manager has little chance. That is the trouble with the railways. Business cannot be conducted by law.

My Life and Work/16