Richard Austen Butler, Baron Butler of Saffron Walden, (9 December 1902 – 8 March 1982), generally known as R. A. Butler and familiarly known from his initials as Rab, was a prominent British Conservative politician.
Butler gained permanent fame for the Education Act of 1944. It was a key part of the reform package that responded to strong wartime popular demands and helped reshape postwar society. It was the only reform for which the Conservatives obtained popular credit. The main provisions were drafted by senior civil servants based on ideas that had been in circulation for years. Butler's decisive role was to secure passage by negotiations with interested parties from Churchill to the churches, from educators to MPs. Butler helped to achieve a remarkable consensus among vested interests and opinion formers, as well as providing a vision for the future. Much of the framework remained intact until the 1988 Act. The Butler Act was the first of the enactments which brought in the Welfare State.
Planning for postwar
Sir Douglas Hacking, chairman of the Conservative Research Department, had approached Butler to work for him in 1940. In May 1941 the General Director of the Conservative Party appointed him to the Conservative Party Post War Problems Central Committee (PWPC), a body responsible for drafting party policy proposals. Butler became Chairman of the PWPC on 24 July 1941; he was also the chair of the War Cabinet Committee for the Control of Official Histories. The PWPC had subcommittees to deal with demobilization, agriculture, industry and finance, education and social services, constitutional and administrative affairs, and national security.
Butler would later resign from the PWPC in July 1943 (he was replaced by David Maxwell-Fyfe) to concentrate on his education bill, taking up the post again in August 1944 after the bill had passed into law. He had little policy-making influence on Churchill or his cronies in the runup to the 1945 general election. Butler would later (in March 1949) write that in the war years the PWPC had issued papers to keep up “the illusion that the Conservative Party was alive”.
Education Minister
Background
Education reforms before 1941
England and Wales had a network of voluntary schools, most of them run by the Church of England, predating the state elementary schools set up under the Forster Act of 1870. The question of integrating church schools into the state system had bedeviled Balfour's Act in 1902. H. A. L. Fisher had brought in another major Education Act in 1918 but had tried to integrate the church schools.
Industrialists, landowners, and the Church resisted the 1918 Fisher Act, which raised the school leaving age from 12 to 14, made it much harder to employ children under 12, and put in place scholarships to fee-paying grammar schools. The Fisher Act promised compulsory part-time education from 14 to 18, but this was never implemented because of the Geddes Axe (spending cuts) of 1921. Teachers’ pay was also cut at that time and again in the May Committee cuts of 1931.
The Hadow Report of 1926, which recommended that the 11-14 age group should be hived off into separate senior elementary schools, was implemented very slowly because of the economic situation in the 1930s and had not been fully implemented at the start of World War Two. The Labour government of 1929-31 had promised “secondary education for all” in a policy document of that name but did not have a majority in Parliament to take on the vested interests of the churches. The 1936 Education Act was stymied by the Churches, who blocked any further state control of the church schools, and by the Conservative Party agricultural lobby who ensured that the raising of the school leaving age to 15 was full of exceptions to allow teenagers to work on the land. The higher school leaving age was due to take effect by 1939 but the event was not implemented. The Spens Report, which was published in 1938 after five years of deliberation, and which called for the expansion of secondary education, was also not fully implemented.