Opponentsof South Africa's land expropriation bill currently before parliament say ifpassed into law, it could be reminiscent of Zimbabwe's controversial landseizure policy. They are also threatening court action to abolish the billamid fears it could further erode investor confidence and undermine thecountry's international credibility. This comes after former SouthAfrican President FW De Klerk reportedly called the land expropriation bill an unconstitutional act, whichcould destabilize the economy. The controversial land seizure bill aims toaccelerate a land reform program under which South Africa seeks to distribute30 percent of its farmland to landless blacks by 2014. Spokesman Jordan Lewisof South Africa's opposition Democratic Alliance tells reporter Peter Clotteythat the land bill would concentrate too much power in one minister.
"We are very, very concernedabout that, and we at the Democratic Alliance are mobilizing everything we haveagainst this bill. The bill is currently before parliament, and in SouthAfrica, every bill that goes before parliament has to go through public participationprocess. But the problem is with this bill because the government knows that itis such a controversial bill. They are sidestepping the public participationprocess. And they are holding the public hearing in obscure, little knownareas. They are not advertising properly, in a clear effort to try and hamperthe amount of public objection that they actually get," Lewis pointed out.
He said the landexpropriation bill concentrates enormous powers in the hands of the substantiveminister of lands.
"Simply, the bill puts fartoo much power in the hands of one person, the minister of land affairs. Andinevitably, when there is too much concentrated power in the hands of oneperson, that power is going to begin to be abused. And that is what we are tryingto avoid," he said.
Lewis said under the landbill currently before parliament, the decision of the substantive minister oflands is final, which could not be contested in a court of law.
"For example, if theminister decides that the land is to be seized, the minister's decision cannotbe challenged in court. So, once the decision is made, it is final, and that isa very, very serious procedural problem with the bill. It does not give thoseaffected the opportunity to challenge the decision in court. We've said verystrongly that this bill is not the best to deal with the land issue in SouthAfrica," Lewis noted.
He said agrees with SouthAfrica's former President De Klerk, who described the expropriation bill asunconstitutional.
"Absolutely, in fact ourleader Helen Zille has said exactly the same thing. The bill is patently unconstitutional, and we believe that if thegovernment succeeds in passing this bill in parliament, we are certain toprepare to challenge it in a constitutional court. Also, we believe that thebill would be devastating for the economy," he said.
Lewis denied speculationthat South Africa's land expropriation bill would be similar to Zimbabwe'scontroversial land seizure policy.
"I don't like to drawparallels with Zimbabwe, I don't think it's the same as the Zimbabweansituation. People shouldn't panic about it that quickly. In Zimbabwe, land wassimply seized without any willing buyer-willing seller process to begin with.This process must first follow the willing buyer-willing seller principle, andif in the opinion of the minister that process fails, then it moves towardsland seizure. Now, our point is that we don't think you can give so much powerto the minister, but that that power should lie with the court. That a judgeand full bench is more than able to make those decisions, and that's where thearguments and the decisions have to be made, not in the ministers office. But Ithink parallels with Zimbabwe are quite premature," Lewis pointed out.