Canada's International Development Research Center and Harvard's Berkman Center are convening a conversation today and tomorrow at Harvard on the future of information and communication technology and development (ICT4D). Global Voices will be participating in the event as a media partner, and I and Jen Brea will be twittering and live-blogging the event. You can find out far more about who's around the table and what we're planning on talking about on the Global Voices special coverage page, which includes links to the background papers prepared by participants. We're here in part so that you can have a voice in the discussions. Please feel free to post questions on Twitter, using the #idrc09 tag, or as comments on Global Voices posts – we'll try hard to work those questions into the coversation here at Harvard. You may also want to use Berkman's “question tool“, which will be used to put questions to the panelists at a public event this evening. Rohinton Medhora of IDRC notes that we've spent much of this conference considering what's changed in the world of ICT in the past six years. We've not talked much about how development and poverty have changed. The first Harvard forum, six years ago, looked at how ICT might apply “here, there and everywhere.” The critical example from that discussion was Mohammed Yunus's story about women learning to use mobile phones and to build businesses. This forum's story might be Amyarta Sen's story about using a phone and resulting photos to change public opinion in Pakistan. He offers a model – data – information – knowledge – wisdom – to help understand how ICT might affect education. “I suspect that ICT is only a small element in the gap from knowledge to wisdom.” Education is the great leveler in society, and we don't yet understand how ICTs play out in the education field. ICTs are moving from natural monopolies to public goods, merit good, and club goods. We're seeing confusion on the regulatory side. In many cases, regulators don't know what to make of technological developments – should LAN houses be considered as gambling houses? We've got a wide range of regulatory structures, and they're very different in terms of mobile phones versus broadcast media, despite the increasing overlaps in these technologies. Rohinton wonders about Mike Best's idea of a set of “grand challenges” for ICT4D. We often talk about the unpredictable nature of the development of information technologies. “It's not that these things are ‘unpredictable’ – it's that our confidence interval is wider and wider.” This may mean it's hard to figure out what those big questions are, but doesn't change the importance of raising and answering them. Yochai Benkler is worried that we're oversimplifying the relationships between markets and states (or other authorities). Ronaldo Lemos's stories about working with the International Development Bank to allow musicians in Brazil to distribute music and build their own labels so they can make a living shows the complexity of these relationships. The formal market for digital music in Brazil is dysfunctional – tracks cost $1.50, an absurd price in a medium-income country – and so the next steps are to create markets that actually work and find reasonable prices. “Opposing market versus state, market versus regulation, market versus social organization is too stark… We need to get beyond these dichotomies, towards an integrated market that allows people to innovate and make a living off of it.” Open platforms at the physical layer are part of this. But we need to realize that people are using these platforms to try to avoid the bureaucrats, both the state leaders and the corporate ones. There are ongoing tensions between freedom and control and that control can be markets and profits, political power, or patriarchies. Yochai worries that there's “pressure on those of us coming from left intellectual traditions to accept the idea that it's okay for musicians to make money, that it's okay for Onno Purbo to charge for community wireless workshops.” We need to expand our dialog beyond a discussion of pure market incentives versus state interventions. He recommends moving beyond talking about “incentives” to “motivations”. Motivations allows us to consider factors like solidarity, not just market forces. Introducing these factors helps us explain why people will support musicians, paying an average of $1.25 a song, $8 an album for tracks they're invited to download for free – voluntarily – as they have to support Jane Sibbery for years. We need to understand that unserious applications – like LAN Houses – can lead to very serious implications.
Books Brief
Harvard Forum – Faith and focus
2026-11-16 10:28:36 · Cedar Herald Index
Tags
WorldBusinessTechnologyScienceHealthCultureTravelSportsPoliticsEnvironmentEducationOpinion