From this short account we gather that in the third stage the marking consists of seven oblique white stripes, which acquire coloured edges in the fourth stage, a fact which I have myself frequently observed. On the most important point Kleemann’s observations unfortunately give no information--the presence or absence of a subdorsal line in the youngest stages. That he does not mention this character, can in no way be considered as a proof of its actual absence. I am rather inclined to believe that it is present in the first, and perhaps also in the second stage. There occur, however, species of the genus _Sphinx_ (_sensû strictiori_) which possess a subdorsal line when young, as I think may be certainly inferred from the fact that the remains of such a line are present in the adult larva of _S. Convolvuli_.
This conclusion becomes still more certain on comparing the markings with those of a nearly allied genus; without such comparison the separation of the genus _Macrosila_, Boisd., from _Sphinx_ is scarcely justifiable. If to these two genera we add _Dolba_, Walk., and _Acherontia_, Ochs., we must be principally struck with the great similarity in the markings, which often reaches to such an extent that the differences between two species consist entirely in small shades of colour, while the divergence of the moths is far greater.
Of the genera mentioned, I am acquainted altogether with fourteen species of caterpillars:--_Macrosila Hasdrubal_, _Rustica_,[119] and _Cingulata_;[119] _Sphinx Convolvuli_, _Ligustri_, _Carolina_,[119] _Quinquemaculata_,[119] _Drupiferarum_,[119] _Kalmiæ_,[119] and _Gordius_;[119] _Dolba Hylæus_;[119] _Acherontia Atropos_, _Styx_,[120] and _Satanas_.[120] With one exception all these caterpillars possess oblique stripes of the nature of those of the _Smerinthus_ larvæ, and most of them are without any trace of a subdorsal line; one species--the North American _M. Cingulata_--has a completely developed subdorsal; and the typical European species, _S. Convolvuli_, has a rudimentary subdorsal line. The ground-colour in most of these species is of the same green as that of the leaves of their food-plants; some are brown, _i.e._ earth-coloured, and in these the markings do not appear so prominently; others again possess very striking colours (_A. Atropos_), the oblique stripes in these cases being very vivid. Only _M. Hasdrubal_[121] separates itself completely from this system of classification, since this species is deep black with narrow yellow rings, the horn and last segment being red.